Lost profits rules for waterworks condemnations

Summary#

HB 421 would amend and reenact § 25.1-230.1 of the Code of Virginia, an existing law on lost access and lost profits in eminent-domain cases. The bill’s title identifies its focus as determining lost profits when a public waterworks system is condemned; it states no separate goal. The bill is at the introduced stage and is not law.

  • For a waterworks system or part of one condemned under the listed laws, the decision-maker must consider the difference between the water-service rates, fees and charges lawfully in effect for the condemning locality or authority and the owner on the valuation date when determining lost profits.
  • On a party’s petition or the court’s request, the lost-profits determination must be reduced to the extent the decision-maker and court find just and reasonable.
  • The section’s text also sets conditions for lost-profits awards in business and farm-operation cases, including proof of the loss, limits on preventable or duplicate losses, and consistent use of generally accepted accounting principles.
  • A business or farm-operation owner seeking lost profits must provide specified federal tax returns. The text limits their disclosure to the condemnation proceeding.
  • The text addresses lost-access compensation, intervention and possible separation of lost-profits proceedings from other compensation issues. The supplied material does not show which of these provisions would be new.

What it means for you#

  • Waterworks owners: In a qualifying condemnation, the decision-maker must consider the rate, fee and charge difference described above when calculating lost profits. The bill does not set a formula for that calculation or require a particular reduction.
  • Businesses and farm operations on property taken or damaged: The text allows lost profits to be included in compensation if the loss is proved with reasonable certainty, directly and proximately caused by the taking or damage, and meets the stated conditions. It also says losses that can reasonably be prevented, covered by relocation assistance or paid elsewhere are not eligible for duplicate compensation.
  • Owners seeking lost profits: They must provide the specified tax returns for the three years before the later of the valuation date or the date use of the land is prevented, and for each year afterward while the case is pending. The text allows a business or farm-operation owner not already named in the case to seek to intervene, and to ask for lost-profits proceedings to be separated from other compensation proceedings.
  • Condemning authorities: The text says they need not include lost-profits liability in their written purchase offer. They may use the tax-return information only in connection with the condemnation proceeding.
  • Others: The bill does not directly change water rates, taxes or eligibility for a public service.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill sets no appropriation, fee or tax.
  • A lost-profits award may affect compensation paid in a condemnation, but the material gives no estimate of how often awards would be made or their amount.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of § 25.1-230.1 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what the bill changes and what it carries forward.
  • The bill does not give a formula for how the water-rate, fee and charge difference affects lost profits, or how to calculate a “just and reasonable” reduction.
  • The supplied text does not explain how the decision-maker would assess or apply that reduction in practice.
  • The bill is at the introduced stage. Whether it will pass, and when any changes would start, are not stated in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that comparing the owner’s charges with the condemning locality’s or authority’s charges gives the decision-maker a specific factor to consider in a waterworks condemnation.
  • Requiring proof, limiting preventable losses and preventing duplicate compensation could help tie awards to losses caused by the taking.
  • Allowing lost-profits issues to be handled separately could let the main compensation proceeding continue without waiting for those issues.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill gives no formula for how rate differences should affect lost profits, making the result harder to predict.
  • The decision-maker and court have room to reduce lost profits by an amount they find just and reasonable, but the text does not explain how to set that amount.
  • Requiring multiple years of tax returns may be burdensome for owners seeking compensation, even though the text restricts their use to the condemnation proceeding.