77°F Cooling Rules Would Cover More Facilities

Summary#

HB 81 would require five Virginia state agencies to amend regulations on temperatures in certain care and correctional facilities. It does not set the new limits directly in the bill; the agencies must make the regulatory changes. The apparent goal is to require lower temperatures or cooling measures in the listed settings.

  • The Department of Social Services must lower the maximum permitted temperature in areas used by residents of licensed assisted living facilities from 80°F to 77°F.
  • It must change the stated cooling-system trigger for rooms in licensed children’s residential facilities, and the trigger for cooling systems used in licensed family day homes, from above 80°F to 77°F.
  • The Department of Juvenile Justice and the Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services must change the stated trigger for providing air conditioning or mechanical ventilation in occupied rooms of the facilities named in the bill from above 80°F to 77°F.
  • The Department of Health must lower the maximum temperature maintained by heating, ventilation and air-conditioning systems in hospice patient areas from 80°F to 77°F.
  • The Department of Corrections must lower the maximum temperature allowed in local correctional-facility rooms from 85°F to 77°F.

What it means for you#

  • Residents, patients, children and people held in correctional facilities: If the agencies amend their regulations as directed, the rules would require lower temperatures or cooling measures in the settings listed. The bill does not create a new application process or state how compliance would be checked.
  • Facility operators: They would be subject to the amended regulations. The bill does not specify equipment standards, deadlines for making changes, or penalties for non-compliance.
  • State agencies: The five named agencies must amend their regulations. The bill does not give a deadline.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change household temperature rules or create a new benefit, tax, fee or fine.
  • HB 81 is introduced and is not law. The supplied material does not establish whether it has passed.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires agencies to amend regulations, but gives no estimate for agency work or facility changes.
  • It does not specify who would pay for cooling equipment, upgrades or higher operating costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current regulations were not supplied, so their exact wording and whether the bill’s stated starting thresholds match current rules could not be checked.
  • The bill does not say when the agencies must amend the regulations or when the changes would take effect.
  • It says cooling systems must be provided or used at a threshold of 77°F, but does not spell out in the bill how that threshold should operate in the regulations.
  • The Department of Social Services and the Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services are both directed to address children’s residential facilities. The bill does not explain how their rules would overlap or be coordinated.
  • The bill does not set equipment standards, inspection rules, compliance steps or penalties.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that lower temperature limits and earlier cooling requirements could reduce exposure to high indoor temperatures for people living in care facilities or held in correctional facilities.
  • Setting a common 77°F figure across the listed settings could make the intended limits easier to understand, though the bill uses different kinds of temperature rules.
  • Requiring the relevant agencies to amend their regulations would place responsibility with agencies that oversee the named settings.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets the same 77°F figure across settings with different rules, but gives no explanation for how that figure was chosen or how it fits each facility type.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of equipment, upgrades or ongoing operation, or say who would bear those costs.
  • Without deadlines, equipment standards or compliance rules in the bill, it is unclear how quickly the changes would take effect or how consistently they would be applied.
  • The two agencies’ directions about children’s residential facilities could create overlapping requirements unless their regulations are coordinated.