Campaign Ads Would Need Synthetic Media Warnings

Summary#

HB-868, “Political campaign advertisements; synthetic media, penalty,” would amend several existing Virginia election and court-venue laws and add a new rule for electioneering communications containing synthetic media. Its apparent goal is to help people recognize when campaign-related messages use altered or artificially generated images or audio. The bill has not become law.

  • A person or committee sponsoring a covered electioneering communication with synthetic media would have to include a conspicuous warning. The warning must appear at the beginning of video or audio messages, and at both the beginning and end if the message is longer than five minutes.
  • For visual messages, the warning must be shown in a font size proportionate to the ad; electronic print ads must use at least seven-point type. The State Board of Elections must set standards for the visual warning.
  • A registered voter who receives a violating communication could ask a court to stop its publication or distribution. Such cases would get priority; a court could award the voter legal costs and fees, and must do so if the voter wins.
  • A sponsor could face a civil penalty of up to $25,000. A willful violation would be a Class 1 misdemeanor.
  • The person accepting a communication for a media outlet would have to check the submitter’s identity and keep proof for one year. Media outlets, internet service providers, and online platforms would not be liable under this section just for carrying a communication without the warning.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: If you receive a covered message that violates the rule, you could bring a court action to seek an order stopping it. This is a legal option, not an automatic review of every ad.
  • Campaigns and other sponsors: You would have to add the warning when a covered electioneering communication uses synthetic media. The rule covers communications about a clearly identified candidate, targeted to that candidate’s electorate, distributed within 60 days of an election, and paid for with money or something of value.
  • Media outlets: The person accepting a communication for publication or broadcast would have to obtain identity proof and keep a copy for one year. For submissions made remotely, the submitter must provide a phone number; the recipient may call to check the information.
  • State Board of Elections: The Board must set standards for the visual warning and would decide whether a violation occurred and whether to assess a civil penalty, after a public hearing.
  • General public: The definition includes certain altered images or audio of real events, and artificially generated images or audio that could be mistaken for real events involving an identifiable person. Satire and parody are exempt. The bill does not require every political ad to be reviewed or approved before publication.
  • Court venue: The bill adds references to the new rule in existing venue laws, which set where related court actions or prosecutions may be brought. The supplied text does not show how those amendments compare with current law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The State Board must set visual-warning standards, and media outlets would have identity-checking and record-retention duties; no staffing or compliance cost estimate is provided.
  • Civil penalties collected would go to Virginia’s general fund. A court may also award a prevailing voter reasonable legal costs and fees.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “fundamentally different” understanding or impression, or set a precise test for when a reasonable person would mistake synthetic media for a real recording.
  • The State Board must set visual-warning standards, but the bill does not specify those standards or when they must be issued.
  • The bill does not set a deadline for deciding a voter’s request to stop a communication, or explain what evidence the voter must provide.
  • The supplied text amends and reenacts several existing laws, but does not include their prior text. I could not verify which wording in those sections would be new, including changes to existing disclosure and online-advertiser rules.
  • The supplied status says the bill is introduced and continued from the last session. It provides no start date or funding plan.

Case for#

  • A warning could tell voters when an election-related message contains certain altered or generated images or audio, rather than leaving them to assume it is an unaltered recording.
  • A court action that receives priority could offer a way to seek a timely stop to a violating message.
  • Requiring sponsors to disclose synthetic media, while exempting satire and parody, could address misleading uses without banning synthetic media outright.

Case against#

  • The terms “fundamentally different” and “reasonable person” leave room for disagreement about which messages need a warning, potentially making compliance difficult.
  • A sponsor could face a large civil penalty and, for a willful violation, criminal punishment; the bill does not spell out detailed criteria for deciding whether a violation is willful.
  • The rule may require quick court decisions about disputed messages, but the bill does not set a decision deadline or detailed process.
  • Media outlets must retain identity proof, but the bill does not explain how that information must be protected.