Millionaire tax would fund schools and housing

Summary#

SB 849, titled “Income tax, state; establishes a new bracket on income above $1 million,” would amend and reenact Virginia Code § 58.1-320, the state individual income tax law. For taxable years beginning January 1, 2027, it would add a 10% tax rate on Virginia taxable income above $1 million; its stated purpose is to direct that tax revenue to schools, child care subsidies, and housing. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The 5.75% rate would apply to income above $17,000 up to $1 million; the 10% rate would apply only to the amount above $1 million (a marginal tax bracket).
  • Revenue from the new 10% rate would be divided: 40% for additional public-school basic aid, 35% for the Child Care Subsidy Program, and 25% for the Virginia Housing Trust Fund.
  • Those funds could not replace existing Commonwealth funding for the three programs; they must increase the total funds available to them.

What it means for you#

  • People with Virginia taxable income above $1 million: From tax years beginning in 2027, the amount above $1 million would be taxed at 10%, rather than 5.75% under the bill’s stated current rate through 2026. The higher rate would not apply to the first $1 million.
  • Other individual taxpayers: The bill does not change their income tax rates in the text provided.
  • Public schools, child care, and housing programs: The bill directs shares of the new tax revenue to these uses. It does not guarantee a particular funding amount.
  • The Commonwealth: It would have to distribute the specified shares and ensure those funds add to, rather than replace, existing funding.

Money#

No publicly available information on expected revenue or implementation costs.

  • The bill directs all revenue from the new 10% rate to the three named uses, in the specified percentages.
  • It provides no revenue estimate, staffing requirement, or implementation cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill uses “Virginia taxable income” but does not define it in this text. The full current Code was not supplied, so the definition and the bill’s changes compared with current law cannot be independently checked here.
  • The bill does not state when or how the revenue would be measured and distributed.
  • It does not specify how the Commonwealth would check that the new funds do not replace existing program funding, or require reporting on that point.
  • The bill gives no estimate of how many taxpayers would owe the higher rate or how much revenue it would raise.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it directs additional revenue from income above $1 million to three named public purposes.
  • The “no supplanting” rule is intended to make the money additional, rather than a replacement for existing state support.
  • The 10% rate applies only to the portion above $1 million, not to all of a taxpayer’s income.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets a higher rate on income above $1 million without providing an estimate of the tax revenue or the number of people affected.
  • The bill directs money to specific programs but does not explain how the state would verify that existing funding is maintained.
  • It is unclear how the distribution would work in practice or what oversight and reporting would apply.