Market-based tax sourcing shift

Summary#

HB 609 would amend Virginia’s corporate income-tax sourcing rules and related provisions of the Code of Virginia. From tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2027, it would generally replace a rule based on where income-producing work is done with rules based on where a sale’s market is; the bill’s stated goal is not provided in the supplied material. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • For most sales other than sales of tangible personal property, a sale would generally be assigned to Virginia if the taxpayer’s Virginia market is involved and its Virginia sales exceed $100,000 in total for the tax year. The bill specifies how to locate the market for real estate, services and different kinds of intangible property.
  • It keeps special sourcing rules for debt buyers, qualifying property information and analytics firms, and qualifying Internet root infrastructure providers. These rules can apply regardless of where the business operates.
  • It allows a telecommunications company to elect to keep using the existing income-producing-activity and cost-of-performance method for eligible tax years from 2027 through 2032. The election is made on the first eligible return and cannot later be changed without the Tax Commissioner’s written approval.
  • Taxpayers may estimate a sale’s Virginia share when necessary information is unavailable, subject to good-faith, reasonableness and tax-avoidance limits. Certain defense contractors must use a population-based estimate for federal-contract sales when the benefit’s location cannot be determined with reasonable good-faith effort.
  • The Department of Taxation must adopt remedies and corrective procedures for abuse of the sourcing rules. The bill also directs the Tax Commissioner and Department to assert tax nexus to the maximum extent permitted by law for the specified special-category sales.

What it means for you#

  • Corporations: For most non-tangible-property sales, the sourcing rule would focus on where the customer receives the benefit or where property is used, rather than where the company performs the work. This may change how much income is assigned to Virginia; the effect on any one company is not stated.
  • Telecommunications companies: They may elect the older sourcing method for eligible years, but cannot switch the election later without written approval.
  • Debt buyers, qualifying property information and analytics firms, and qualifying Internet root infrastructure providers: Their specified sales would be sourced to Virginia under special rules, even if their business operations are elsewhere. The property-information and Internet-root provisions have employee, investment or agreement conditions.
  • Taxpayers generally: The bill changes how sales are assigned for corporate income-tax purposes. It does not change the corporate income-tax rate or create a new tax.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied material gives no estimate of added or reduced state revenue, administrative costs, or business compliance costs.
  • The bill could change how much income particular corporations assign to Virginia, but the revenue effect is unknown.
  • The bill gives the Department a duty to adopt remedies and corrective procedures, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define how to determine where a service’s “benefit” is received in all cases, or how the Department will assess estimates and abuse.
  • It does not provide the Department’s procedures for estimate approval, or details of the corrective procedures it must adopt.
  • The special eligibility provisions include date changes alongside requirements tied to later dates, including 2029 and 2028. The supplied text does not explain how those dates work together in practice.
  • The bill does not estimate how many taxpayers would be affected or how their Virginia tax bills would change.

Case for#

  • A market-based rule links sales to where customers receive a service or use property, rather than where the seller carries out its work.
  • The bill gives specific sourcing rules for real estate, services and types of intangible property, which could make the treatment clearer for different kinds of sales.
  • The $100,000 threshold and the option for telecommunications companies to elect the older method limit the reach of the general change for some taxpayers.

Case against#

  • A company may have less access to information about where a customer receives a service or uses intangible property than about where the company performs its work. The bill permits estimates, but leaves key procedures to the Department.
  • The special rules and eligibility conditions may make tax sourcing less uniform across businesses.
  • The bill directs the Department to assert nexus as far as the law permits, but does not specify how that direction will be applied in individual cases.