Carbon Auction Exit Would Fund Utility Credits

Summary#

SB 852, titled “Virginia Clean Energy & Community Flood Preparedness Act; repeal, electric utility customer credit,” is an introduced bill that would amend five sections of Virginia law and repeal an article containing three sections. Its main changes are to direct the state to stop participating in a Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) allowance auction and to send certain RGGI revenue to utilities for customer bill credits. The bill’s stated goal, as reflected in its title, is to repeal the clean-energy provisions and provide an electric utility customer credit.

  • The Department of Environmental Quality director must take steps to suspend the Commonwealth’s participation in the RGGI-related auction program.
  • The bill repeals the article that includes the cited RGGI provisions.
  • The Commonwealth must send revenue collected through the program to utilities that meet the bill’s conditions. Those utilities must credit their Virginia customers, on bills as a line item labeled “RGGI Credit,” in a manner approved by the State Corporation Commission.
  • The bill also amends laws on flood-preparedness funding, environmental reporting, air pollution, power-plant closure notices, and energy-efficiency targets. The supplied text does not show which wording in those sections is new.
  • The bill is introduced and has not become law. Its passage is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • Customers of eligible utilities: If your utility receives money under the bill, it must pass that money to its Virginia customers as a bill credit. The bill does not set the credit amount or explain how it would be divided among customers.
  • Utilities: A utility qualifies if it has an approved or pending rate-adjustment petition to recover emissions-allowance costs, or has otherwise increased customer bills to recover those costs. It must distribute funds it receives as the Commission approves.
  • State agencies: The Department of Environmental Quality director must take steps to suspend the Commonwealth’s auction participation. The Commission would approve how utilities provide the credits.
  • Local governments, tribes, and other groups: The bill includes amended text about flood-preparedness funding and other topics, but the supplied text does not show what changes those amendments would make to current law.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill requires the Commonwealth to remit collected program revenue to qualifying utilities, which must provide customer credits. It gives no amount or allocation formula.
  • The bill does not state a cost estimate for suspending auction participation or administering the credits.
  • It does not create a new tax or customer fee in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended laws and marked-up bill text were not supplied. It is not possible to verify what changes the bill would make to the flood fund, reporting, air-pollution, plant-closure, or energy-efficiency rules.
  • The bill repeals provisions that it also refers to in the amended text. For example, the flood fund text refers to revenue under a repealed provision, and the energy-efficiency text refers to programs authorized by a repealed provision. The bill does not explain how those cross-references would work.
  • The bill does not say how the collected revenue would be divided among eligible utilities or how each utility’s customer credit would be calculated.
  • No publicly available information is provided on how much revenue is involved or when credits would appear on bills.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that customers whose bills included recovered allowance costs should receive a direct credit from the collected program revenue.
  • Requiring the credit to appear as a separate bill line could make the credit visible to customers.
  • The bill assigns the credit process to existing utilities and requires Commission approval, rather than setting up a new agency to distribute customer payments.

Case against#

  • Repealing the cited article and suspending auction participation could affect revenue connected in the bill text to flood-preparedness and energy-efficiency programs. The bill does not explain how those programs or funding sources would continue.
  • The bill leaves the credit amount and allocation method unstated, so customers cannot tell what credit they might receive.
  • The unreconciled references to repealed provisions could create uncertainty about the flood fund and energy-efficiency rules.
  • The bill provides no cost estimate or schedule for the credits.