Nuclear Credits Could Count Toward Energy Targets

Summary#

SB 856 would amend and reenact Virginia’s Electric Utility Regulation Act section on renewable and zero-carbon electricity. Its main change is to add nuclear generating facilities located in Virginia to the sources that can qualify for the state’s renewable energy portfolio standard (RPS); the apparent goal is to give utilities another source they can use to meet RPS requirements. The bill is introduced and has not become law.

  • Virginia’s Phase I and Phase II electric utilities must meet annual RPS requirements by procuring and retiring renewable energy certificates (RECs). The bill would make RECs from in-state nuclear facilities eligible for that purpose.
  • The bill does not require utilities to buy nuclear electricity or build nuclear facilities. It adds an eligible source for meeting existing requirements.
  • The supplied bill text includes a rule allowing utilities to recover RPS compliance costs from retail customers through a charge. Whether that rule changes is unclear without the current law for comparison.

What it means for you#

  • Electric utility customers: You would not be required to buy nuclear power directly. If utilities use nuclear RECs to meet RPS requirements, the effect on customer charges is unknown.
  • Utilities: They would have another eligible source for RPS compliance, but the bill does not require them to use it.
  • Nuclear facilities in Virginia: Their electricity could qualify for RPS compliance under the bill. It does not change facility ownership or require new construction or continued operation.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill makes no specific appropriation.
  • The bill text says RPS compliance costs, including REC costs, can be recovered from retail customers. If utilities buy nuclear RECs, the effect on costs is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the amended law was not supplied, so I could not verify which provisions in the bill’s rewritten text are new and which already apply.
  • The bill does not explain how nuclear RECs would be created, verified, or tracked.
  • It does not define “nuclear facilities” or set further conditions, such as a facility’s operating date.
  • The bill does not estimate how many nuclear RECs might be available, whether utilities would use them, or how their use might affect compliance costs or the mix of other eligible sources.

Case for#

  • The change would give utilities another option for meeting RPS requirements.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that electricity from in-state nuclear facilities meets the bill’s definition of zero-carbon electricity, so allowing it to count could broaden the supply of qualifying certificates.
  • More eligible sources could give utilities greater flexibility in meeting their required targets; the bill does not say whether this would lower costs.

Case against#

  • One concern is that allowing nuclear RECs to count could reduce the share of RPS compliance met by other eligible sources, including solar and wind.
  • The bill adds nuclear facilities as an eligible source without setting specific rules for how their RECs are issued or verified.
  • It is unclear whether the change would reduce, increase, or leave unchanged the costs customers pay for RPS compliance.