Custody presumption would be 50/50

Summary#

HB 2735 would add a section to Washington’s family-law chapter, chapter 26.09 RCW. It sets out principles the Legislature intends courts to follow in family-law cases; its stated goal is to establish a “constitutional floor” for parental and children’s rights. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • It states that parents are presumed fit unless the state proves otherwise, and describes a 50/50 custody arrangement as the presumption unless parents agree to another arrangement. It says concrete, proven violence, substance abuse, or neglect negates “this presumption,” but does not make clear which presumption that means.
  • It says any intrusion on the parent-child bond must meet strict scrutiny (a demanding constitutional test) and use the least restrictive means.
  • It says similarly situated parents must be treated equally and parents must cooperate through enforceable behaviors meant to prevent sabotage and keep both homes functional.
  • It says advisors may advise but judges alone decide; court orders must be clear and contestable, and secret evidence or one-way pipelines may not be permitted.
  • It gives the act the short title “Troxel II.” It does not create a new agency or program.

What it means for you#

  • Parents in family-law cases: The bill sets out a fitness presumption, a 50/50 custody presumption, and a duty to cooperate. It does not explain how these principles would apply when parents disagree or how the required cooperation would be enforced.
  • Judges and advisors: The bill says judges must make decisions, while advisors may advise. It also sets standards for orders and evidence, but does not provide procedures for applying them.
  • Children and the public: The bill describes children as having a natural right to be raised by fit parents. It does not create a separate service or process for children.
  • Current law: The text of chapter 26.09 RCW was not supplied, so I could not verify how these provisions compare with current Washington law or how they would interact with existing rules.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation, cost estimate, staffing requirement, fee, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “fit,” “concrete proven,” “sabotage,” “one-way pipelines,” or what makes an order “contestable.”
  • It is unclear whether the 50/50 language directs a court to start from equal custody when parents disagree, or describes a presumption about what parents will agree to.
  • “This presumption” is not clearly tied to either the fitness presumption or the 50/50 custody presumption.
  • The bill does not set out how evidence would be tested, how parents could challenge orders, or how cooperation would be enforced.
  • It does not say when the new section would take effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that clear presumptions and limits on state intervention could protect parents’ liberty interests in raising their children.
  • Requiring judges, rather than advisors, to decide cases could make responsibility for decisions clearer.
  • Equal-treatment and evidence rules could help make family-law orders more transparent and open to challenge.
  • A stated focus on cooperation could encourage arrangements that keep both parents involved, where that is safe and appropriate.

Case against#

  • The bill states broad principles but leaves key terms and procedures undefined, so parents and courts may not know how to apply them consistently.
  • It is unclear how the 50/50 custody presumption would work in disputed cases or how it would relate to a child’s specific circumstances.
  • The bill does not explain how its new principles fit with existing family-law rules; the supplied material does not allow that comparison.
  • Requiring enforceable cooperation without defining the required behaviors or enforcement process could leave important decisions to later interpretation.