Custody presumption favors shared parenting time

Summary#

SF-5298, “Custody and parenting time provisions modification,” would amend Minnesota’s custody and parenting-time laws in sections 518.17 and 518.175. It would create new rebuttable presumptions about joint custody and parenting time; the bill does not state a broader goal.

  • If either parent asks for joint legal and physical custody, a court would have to presume that arrangement is in the child’s best interests, unless the presumption is rebutted.
  • If domestic abuse has occurred between the parents, the bill would instead require a rebuttable presumption that joint legal or physical custody is not in the child’s best interests.
  • Unless there is other evidence, a court would have to presume that a child receive at least 50 percent of parenting time with each parent. In practice, that points to equal time, but the presumption could be rebutted.
  • Courts would still have to assess the child’s best interests and make detailed findings. If parenting time is likely to endanger the child or impair the child’s emotional development, the court must restrict it and may deny it entirely.

What it means for you#

  • Parents in custody cases: If either parent requests joint legal and physical custody, the court would start from the view that it is in the child’s best interests. Evidence could rebut that presumption. A history of domestic abuse between the parents would create a contrary presumption against joint legal or physical custody.
  • Parents seeking parenting time: A court would start from a presumption of at least 50 percent of parenting time with each parent, unless there is other evidence. The bill allows time to be counted by overnights or, in some cases, significant periods on separate days.
  • Children and families: The bill would not guarantee equal time or joint custody. The court must consider the child’s best interests, and safety-related restrictions remain possible.
  • Courts: Judges would have to apply the new presumptions while considering the listed best-interest factors and explaining their decisions in detailed findings.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied bill text contains no cost estimate or appropriation.
  • It would change what courts must presume in custody and parenting-time decisions. Any resulting court or public costs are not stated.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current versions of the amended statutes, so the full changes from current law could not be verified. The bill text indicates it would change the parenting-time presumption from 25 percent to 50 percent.
  • The bill does not explain what evidence would be enough to rebut either presumption.
  • It is unclear how courts should weigh the 50-percent presumption against a child’s individual needs and the other best-interest factors.
  • The supplied text gives no effective date. The bill is introduced and passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a clear starting point for shared parenting time could help children maintain relationships with both parents.
  • The joint-custody presumption could make the starting point clearer when a parent asks for joint custody.
  • The presumptions are rebuttable, and the bill keeps the court’s ability to restrict or deny parenting time when the child’s safety or emotional development is at risk.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a 50-percent starting presumption could be difficult to overcome even when a different schedule better fits a child’s needs.
  • The bill does not explain how much evidence is needed to rebut the presumptions, leaving an important part of their application unclear.
  • A possible trade-off is that a general presumption of joint custody may not fit every family’s circumstances; the bill creates a separate contrary presumption when domestic abuse has occurred between the parents.