Custody would start with shared parenting time

Summary#

SB 2383 would add four sections to and amend three sections of North Dakota’s law on parental rights and responsibilities. Its title identifies equal decision-making, parenting time, best-interest factors and a child’s residence; the bill text gives no separate statement of its goal. The bill failed to pass, so it did not change the law.

  • It would presume both parents fit. A court could not use the best-interest factors unless a party proved a parent unfit by clear and convincing evidence (a high standard of proof), or the court found equal residential responsibility inappropriate.
  • It would require equal residential responsibility unless an exception applied. Exceptions include certain cases involving distance, infants, a child’s documented special needs, a parent’s inability to use all parenting time, or an agreement reached through mediation.
  • It would define equal decision-making as both parents communicating and agreeing on major, non-routine decisions, including day care, education, activities, health care and spiritual development. Equal parenting time would mean 50% of the time, or as close to that as circumstances allow.
  • It would change rules for moving a child’s residence out of state. For parents with equal residential responsibility, a move beyond 50 miles would generally need the other parent’s written consent or a court order that allows the move and gives the moving parent primary residential responsibility.
  • It would apply to actions involving a child under 18. For a first qualifying motion filed after the effective date, it would set aside certain existing limits on changing a post-judgment order or amending an interim order.

What it means for you#

  • Parents in a court case: If enacted, the bill would make equal residential responsibility the starting rule, not a result the court could reach only after weighing the best-interest factors. Those factors would apply if a parent were found unfit or equal responsibility were found inappropriate.
  • Parents with special circumstances: The bill sets out exceptions. For example, if parents live too far apart, neither will move closer, and equal responsibility would harm the child, the court must give the other parent the maximum parenting time possible. If an infant’s circumstances do not allow exchanges at least every seven days, or a child’s documented special needs make equal responsibility harmful, the court must set a schedule based on the child’s best interests.
  • Parents who agree to a different arrangement: A court must consider an agreement reached through mediation, unless it finds the arrangement harmful to the child’s physical or emotional health.
  • Parents moving with a child: The bill also sets out exceptions to the move restrictions, including when the other parent has not exercised parenting time for a year, proved by clear and convincing evidence. That exception would not apply if the other parent is an active-duty service member.
  • Children and families: The bill includes a new statement that children and parents in cases under this chapter may not be denied due process or equal protection. Because SB 2383 failed, none of these proposed changes took effect under this bill.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost.

  • The bill contains no appropriation or cost estimate in the supplied text.
  • It would impose new directions on courts, but the materials give no estimate of any added court workload or cost.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the North Dakota Century Code is not supplied. I cannot verify which wording in the amended definitions, best-interest factors and residence rules is already law, or how much of it would be new.
  • The bill does not define key terms such as “unfit,” “inherently unable,” “infant” or “proper care,” or explain how courts should apply them.
  • It does not set out a separate process, timeline or appeal rule for deciding whether a parent is unfit or equal residential responsibility is inappropriate.
  • It does not explain how the new rules would interact with other existing court orders beyond the specific limits it says would not apply to a first qualifying motion.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would give both parents an equal starting position and bar courts from giving one parent priority based on gender, race, creed or religion.
  • The presumption of fitness and the high proof standard could be seen as protecting parents from losing a role in major decisions or residential responsibility without strong evidence.
  • The bill includes exceptions for several situations where equal residential responsibility may not suit a child, including harmful distance, an infant’s schedule and documented special needs.
  • Requiring parents to agree on major non-routine decisions could encourage shared involvement in a child’s upbringing.

Case against#

  • One concern is that requiring clear and convincing evidence of unfitness before a court may consider best-interest factors could limit an individualized assessment of what arrangement suits a child.
  • Equal residential responsibility would be the required outcome unless an exception applied. The bill does not explain how courts should assess some of those exceptions, leaving important terms open to interpretation.
  • The special-needs exception requires documentation by a child development expert, but the bill does not say who selects or pays for the expert.
  • The bill would let a first qualifying motion proceed without certain limits on changing an existing order. The supplied material does not explain how that change might affect families with existing arrangements.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1494363

    Defeated47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 35FOR · 12

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    35Against

    • Republican30
    • Democratic5

    12For

    • Republican12