High earners face 9.9% income tax if approved

Summary#

HB 2738 would create a new Washington income-tax law, adding Title 82A to state law and amending several existing laws. It would impose a 9.9% tax on an individual’s Washington taxable income after deductions, starting in 2028, but only if voters approve a constitutional amendment authorizing the tax. Its stated goal is to fund tax relief and local public-defense funding.

  • The Department of Revenue would administer the tax. Individuals generally would owe it on taxable income above a $1 million standard deduction; spouses or registered domestic partners would share a $2 million deduction.
  • Residents would generally include income from all sources; nonresidents would include income sourced to Washington under rules in the bill.
  • Taxpayers could claim certain credits, including for income taxes paid to another jurisdiction, Washington capital-gains tax, and some business taxes.
  • Seven percent of tax revenue would go to a local-government public-defense account. The rest would go to the state general fund for specified tax-relief programs.
  • The bill also allows pass-through businesses, such as partnerships and S corporations, to elect to pay the tax for owners’ income.

What it means for you#

  • Individuals and households: The tax is based on “Washington taxable income,” not simply gross or federal income. The bill allows deductions and adjustments that affect that calculation. Spouses and registered domestic partners are treated together for deduction limits and other amounts, even if they file separate state returns; their tax liability is generally joint.
  • Washington residents: The bill generally counts all income, including income from outside Washington. It defines residency using domicile or, in some cases, presence in Washington for more than 183 days.
  • Nonresidents: The bill would tax specified Washington-source income, including some wages, business income, property income, and income from professional athletics or student-athlete name, image, and likeness activity.
  • Taxpayers who owe the tax: They would generally file electronically and include a copy of their federal income-tax return and related documents. Estimated payments would be required for some taxpayers, but not before July 1, 2029.
  • Businesses and teams: A pass-through entity may elect to pay tax for its owners. Businesses paying qualifying professional athletes would have to report information to the Department of Revenue.
  • Current law: The existing statutes being amended and the full bill are not included, so I could not verify which related rules already exist or how much of the bill changes current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s implementation costs or a revenue estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill sets the tax rate at 9.9% and directs 7% of collections to local public-defense funding; the remainder is intended for specified tax-relief programs.
  • The bill requires tax administration, including rules, returns, and collection, but the supplied text gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The referenced tax-relief provisions are not included in the supplied text, so their amounts and eligibility rules cannot be described here.

What is unclear#

  • The bill is at first reading and is not law. The supplied text says the tax depends on passage of a constitutional amendment, but does not include that amendment or say what would happen if it is not approved.
  • The supplied bill text ends before all provisions, including its effective-date and expiration details. No publicly available information in the supplied material gives the full start and end conditions.
  • The exact tax calculation depends on extensive income adjustments and credits. The supplied material does not include all referenced provisions or the full bill.
  • The supplied material does not explain how the tax would interact with existing programs beyond the credits and revenue uses described above.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material gives an estimate of how many people or businesses would be affected.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to raise money from individuals with high Washington taxable income while directing most revenue to tax-relief programs and some to local public defense.
  • A possible argument for the design is that the large standard deduction limits the tax to taxable income above $1 million for an individual, or $2 million for spouses or registered domestic partners, subject to the bill’s calculation rules.
  • Credits for some taxes paid elsewhere or already paid on the same income could reduce certain forms of double taxation.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the tax and its extensive income rules could be difficult for taxpayers and the Department of Revenue to administer; the supplied text provides no cost estimate.
  • The bill depends on a constitutional amendment, and the supplied material does not show the amendment or explain what would happen if it fails.
  • It is unclear how much of the revenue would reach each tax-relief program because the referenced provisions are not included in the supplied text.
  • The bill creates criminal penalties for certain knowing violations, but the supplied material does not provide the full penalty details or explain how enforcement would work in practice.