Constitutional amendment could permit income tax

Summary#

HJR 4213 is a joint resolution proposing an amendment to Washington’s Constitution; it does not itself impose an income tax. If voters approve it at the next general election, the Legislature may impose an income tax, subject to limits. The stated aim is to allow income taxation while setting a minimum income threshold and a maximum tax rate.

  • The proposed amendment says income is not property for tax purposes and gives the Legislature power to tax income from any source.
  • Any income tax must not apply to people with Washington taxable income of $1 million a year or less. That threshold would be adjusted each year using Seattle-area consumer prices.
  • Any income tax’s maximum rate could not exceed 9.9 percent.
  • The Secretary of State must submit the amendment to voters and publish notice of it before the election.
  • The resolution is at first reading and is not law. Even if voters approve it, the Legislature would still have to pass a law to impose a tax.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: The proposed constitutional amendment would go to voters at the next general election.
  • People with Washington taxable income at or below the threshold: An income tax created under this amendment could not apply to them.
  • People above the threshold: They could be subject to an income tax if the Legislature later creates one. The amendment does not say what income would be taxed or how the tax would be calculated.
  • Legislature: It would gain authority to impose an income tax, but would not be required to do so. The tax would have to follow the threshold and rate limits.
  • People generally: The proposal does not itself set a tax rate, collect tax, or change other taxes.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is in the available material.

  • The proposal does not itself impose a tax or specify how much revenue a future tax might raise.
  • The text gives no estimate for the cost of holding the vote or publishing notice.

What is unclear#

  • The proposal does not define “Washington taxable income” or say how a future tax would treat income above $1 million—for example, whether tax could apply to all of a person’s income or only the amount above the threshold.
  • It does not set a tax rate, tax brackets, exemptions, filing rules, or enforcement process. Those details would require further legislation.
  • The current constitutional text was not supplied, so the existing rules and the full legal change cannot be verified from the available material.
  • The text does not say how the amendment would interact with other constitutional tax rules.

Case for#

  • The proposal could give the Legislature a way to tax income while preventing a tax under this authority on people at or below the stated threshold.
  • A constitutional maximum rate would limit how high a future income tax rate could be.
  • Adjusting the income threshold for Seattle-area price changes could keep the stated threshold from remaining fixed as prices change.

Case against#

  • The amendment would give the Legislature broad authority to tax income from any source, while leaving the tax’s structure and actual rates for later laws.
  • The threshold may not settle how a future tax treats people just above $1 million; the proposal does not specify whether tax could apply to all their income or only income above the threshold.
  • The proposal does not explain how this new authority would fit with existing constitutional tax rules.