Study water loss to stabilize rates

Summary#

HCR-25 is a concurrent resolution asking the Joint Committee on Government and Finance to study ways to reduce non-revenue water in West Virginia public water systems. It does not amend an existing Act or establish a water-loss program; its stated goal is to examine possible ways to reduce water loss and stabilize rates.

  • The requested study would identify and prioritize systems with the highest water losses, and examine leak detection, infrastructure management, metering, and pressure controls.
  • The committee is asked to assess how water loss affects system costs and customer rates, and whether savings from reducing losses could be reinvested in repairs and upgrades.
  • It is asked to examine possible state support, such as shared equipment, technical assistance, financing, and performance-based incentives. These could include grant priority, better loan terms, faster project review, or grants tied to verified reductions.
  • The resolution asks the committee to consider safeguards so small and rural systems have technical help and reasonable ways to qualify.
  • The requested report is due to the Legislature by December 1, 2026. The resolution is introduced and referred to House Rules; it is not yet adopted.

What it means for you#

  • Households: The resolution would not change water bills, rates, or service. Rate stabilization is a subject for the study, not a promised result.
  • Public water systems: The resolution would not require systems to find or repair leaks, meet efficiency benchmarks, apply for assistance, or change their infrastructure. Those options would be examined.
  • Small and rural systems: The study is asked to consider technical assistance and fair ways to qualify for possible incentives. No assistance or incentive program is created.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The resolution requests a study; it does not approve bonds, loans, grants, or spending for water-system improvements.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution authorizes no spending, staffing, grants, loans, bonds, or customer charges.
  • It asks the committee to study possible financing tools and incentives, but does not establish them.
  • The cost of carrying out the study is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution asks the committee to study the issue but does not specify its methods, staff, budget, or whether it will consult water systems or customers.
  • It gives no measure or threshold for “high” non-revenue water or for qualifying as a “high performing” system.
  • It does not say how any future assistance or incentives would be funded, awarded, or checked.
  • The resolution does not say whether or how savings from reduced water loss would lower customer rates.
  • It sets a report deadline but does not require the Legislature to adopt any recommendations.

Case for#

  • A study could help the Legislature identify which systems lose the most water and what kinds of repairs or management changes may be useful.
  • The requested review would consider whether reducing treated water losses could lower operating costs and ease pressure on customer rates.
  • Examining shared equipment and technical help could help the Legislature assess options for smaller systems, not just those already able to meet efficiency targets.
  • Studying safeguards alongside performance incentives could help identify ways to reward improvements without leaving small or rural systems behind.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not require any repairs or other action, so water losses and their costs would continue unless later steps are taken.
  • It does not provide funding or require a follow-up decision, leaving unclear whether any recommendations would lead to programs or improvements.
  • Incentives based on efficiency could be harder for small or rural systems to qualify for; the resolution asks the committee to study safeguards but does not set them.
  • The title’s aim of stabilizing rates is not guaranteed: the resolution only requests an examination of potential savings and rate effects.