Wholesale of certain low-proof spirits allowed

Summary#

SB-1049, “Allowing retail liquor licensees to wholesale certain low-proof alcohol to class A and class B retailers,” would amend West Virginia’s Alcoholic Liquors Code and add a new article. Its stated goal is to let retail liquor licensees sell certain ready-to-drink distilled products wholesale to Class A and Class B retailers for sale to consumers. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • It defines covered products as distilled drinks that are not wine or beer, contain 0.05% to 15.5% alcohol by volume, and come in containers of no more than 16 fluid ounces.
  • Retail liquor licensees could choose to act as wholesalers of those products to Class A and Class B retailers.
  • The wholesale markup could not exceed 22%. The bill does not set a consumer retail price limit.
  • A liquor licensee could choose to deliver orders of at least 25 cases, subject to rules set by the Commissioner.
  • Wholesaling would cost $250 per year. Delivery would cost an additional $250 per year.
  • The Commissioner may propose rules to implement the new article.

What it means for you#

  • Retail liquor licensees: You could wholesale covered products to Class A and Class B retailers, but would not have to. To deliver, you would need to opt in, pay the separate delivery fee, and meet the 25-case minimum.
  • Class A and Class B retailers: You could buy these products from retail liquor licensees for sale to consumers. The bill does not change the other requirements for your existing license.
  • Consumers: The bill aims to make these drinks available at more locations, but does not require any retailer to stock them or guarantee wider availability.
  • The Commissioner and taxpayers: The Commissioner may propose implementing rules. The bill does not create a new agency or set a public spending amount.

The bill says these products are currently distributed and sold under another part of the Code. The current text of that law was not supplied, so that description could not be checked against current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on total public cost or staffing.

  • Licensees that wholesale would pay $250 a year. Those that also deliver would pay another $250 a year. Both fees are non-refundable and cannot be prorated.
  • The bill sets no estimate for the Commissioner’s rulemaking or other implementation costs.
  • No tax change, public appropriation, or consumer price limit is stated in the bill.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how the 22% wholesale markup is calculated.
  • It does not set rules for ordering, records, oversight, or enforcement. The Commissioner may propose rules, and deliveries must follow rules that are in place.
  • The bill does not state when the changes would take effect.
  • The supplied material does not include the current law governing distribution, so the full effect on existing licensing and distribution rules is unclear.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let more licensed retailers sell a defined group of lower-alcohol distilled drinks to consumers.
  • Using existing retail liquor licensees as wholesalers could add a distribution option without creating a new agency.
  • A 22% wholesale markup limit could constrain the amount added at the wholesale stage, though it does not control the final retail price.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how to calculate the markup limit, which could leave room for disagreement about what it allows.
  • A possible trade-off is more retail access in exchange for another licensed wholesale channel and added rules for the Commissioner to develop.
  • The bill sets fees but gives no estimate of public implementation costs or detail on how the new channel would fit with existing distribution rules.