New nonprofit to run spirits program

Summary#

SB 1062, titled “Creating TEAM-WV,” would add a new article to the West Virginia Code and a new section on the spirits business; it is an introduced bill, not law. It would require the Governor to form TEAM-WV as a nonprofit corporation, governed by a board and led by a board-appointed chief executive officer. Its stated goal is to promote economic development, jobs, training, and business recruitment.

  • The Department of Commerce could contract with TEAM-WV to help carry out department duties, including running programs, offices, divisions, or boards. The department would keep authority to approve or reject awards involving public money.
  • The state could transfer some or all of its spirits distribution and merchandising assets or rights to TEAM-WV. If it does, TEAM-WV must pay the state at least $30 million a year in monthly installments. A transfer could last up to 25 years, with a possible 15-year extension by agreement.
  • Even after a transfer, a contract must provide for the Alcohol Beverage Control Commission to keep operating spirits distribution and merchandising and to keep controlling spirits traffic and setting wholesale and retail prices.
  • TEAM-WV would be a nonprofit corporation, not a state agency. Its directors and employees would not be state employees. The corporation could have subsidiaries.
  • The bill requires annual financial audits, annual reports, conflict-of-interest rules, and some public board meetings and records. Some meetings may be closed, and many TEAM-WV records would not be public unless designated for public access in its Commerce contract.
  • The Commerce Secretary would have to review economic-development duties and report recommendations to the Legislature, including possible transfers of duties to TEAM-WV or other agencies.

What it means for you#

  • Taxpayers and the public: The state could use a nonprofit corporation to help deliver Commerce services. The bill does not require the state to transfer the spirits business or guarantee that TEAM-WV will produce jobs or other economic results.
  • Businesses seeking state incentives: TEAM-WV could advise and assist the department, and could operate programs under contract. The department would retain approval authority for awards involving public money, and grant, loan, or tax-incentive contracts would remain between the department and recipients.
  • People buying spirits: If a transfer happens, the Commission must continue operating distribution and merchandising under contract and keep setting wholesale and retail prices. The bill does not itself set new prices.
  • TEAM-WV directors and staff: They would work for the nonprofit, not the state. Directors would generally serve without pay but could be reimbursed for actual, necessary expenses. The bill also sets conflict-of-interest, ethics, and audit requirements.
  • People seeking information: Some records, including specified financial and incentive records, must be made available under the Commerce contract. Other records held by TEAM-WV would not automatically be public. Public board meetings may be closed for listed reasons, including business strategy and proprietary information.
  • Former state employees hired by TEAM-WV: The bill says they would no longer be considered public employees under the state public-employee retirement law when their TEAM-WV employment begins.

Money#

The bill gives no estimate of its net public cost or revenue effect.

  • Commerce could pay TEAM-WV from funds appropriated to the department for contracted work. TEAM-WV would also need staff, audits, and other services, but the bill gives no cost estimates.
  • If the state transfers spirits assets or rights, TEAM-WV must pay the state at least $30 million per year; the proceeds go to the state’s general revenue fund. No transfer is required.
  • The bill would exempt transferred spirits-business property and TEAM-WV income from specified state and local taxes.
  • The state could hire appraisers, underwriters, investment bankers, and financial advisers for a transfer. No costs are stated.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify which spirits assets or rights would be transferred, or provide a transfer agreement. It allows a transfer of all or part of the defined business.
  • It does not explain how TEAM-WV would select projects or applicants, measure individual incentive decisions, or handle appeals.
  • The bill does not set a budget, staffing level, or expected financial return for TEAM-WV.
  • The scope of records made public would depend partly on the Commerce contract. The bill lists records that must be designated for public access, but otherwise limits public access to TEAM-WV records.
  • The bill uses terms such as “major contracts” and “appropriate compensation” without specifying their thresholds or amounts.
  • The current versions of the amended Code sections were not supplied, so the bill’s changes to existing law and the existing spirits system cannot be fully checked against current law. The text also gives no effective date. Passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to coordinate economic-development work through one corporation that can contract with Commerce and assist with its programs and duties.
  • A possible argument for a nonprofit structure is that it could give the state a dedicated organization for business recruitment and economic-development work.
  • Required audits, conflict rules, annual reports, and public records listed in the contract could provide oversight of the corporation.
  • If a spirits transfer occurs, the state would receive at least $30 million a year, while the Commission would continue operating the business and setting prices.

Case against#

  • TEAM-WV could take on public functions while remaining outside the state government, and most of its records would not automatically be public.
  • The state could transfer valuable spirits assets or rights for as long as 25 years, with a possible 15-year extension, but the bill does not identify what would be transferred or provide the actual agreement.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of staffing TEAM-WV, paying for its work, audits, or a spirits transfer. Its tax exemptions could also reduce state or local revenue.
  • A possible trade-off is that constitutional challenges to the law or TEAM-WV actions would face short filing deadlines: generally 90 days after the law takes effect or 60 days after the challenged action.