Stadium price cap on concessions

Summary#

AB 1163, titled “Unfair sales practices at publicly funded stadiums,” would have created two sections of Wisconsin law; it would not have amended an existing Act. Its stated aim, reflected in the title, was to limit food and drink prices at certain publicly supported stadiums. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Stadium owners, operators and concessionaires would have been barred from selling or offering food or drinks inside a covered stadium for more than the retailer’s cost plus a markup of up to 20%.
  • The retailer’s cost would have been calculated using an existing provision of Wisconsin law. The parent law is not included in the supplied materials, so its calculation cannot be checked here.
  • The cap would have applied to multipurpose facilities in Wisconsin designed and mainly used for sports or entertainment, with room for at least 3,000 people, whose owner receives public financial support related to the facility.
  • “Public financial support” includes government payments, grants, loans, tax reductions or incentives, and proceeds from tax-exempt bonds.
  • Facilities owned or leased by a school board, private school, charter-school operator or tribal school’s governing body would have been excluded. The bill would have made violations an unfair trade practice; the supplied legislative analysis says the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection could enforce it.

What it means for you#

  • Stadium customers: If the bill had become law, food and drink prices inside covered stadiums would have been subject to the cost-plus-20% limit. It would not have set prices at other venues or outside the stadium.
  • Stadium owners, operators and concessionaires: They would have had to keep covered sales within the limit. The bill does not require them to sell any particular food or drink.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes or require a payment to stadiums. Its definition of covered stadiums includes facilities receiving certain forms of public financial support.
  • Everyone: The bill failed, so none of these requirements took effect.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s implementation costs or effects on public revenue.

  • The bill contains no appropriation or cost estimate.
  • It could have affected revenue from covered food and drink sales, but the supplied material does not estimate the effect or say who would bear any resulting costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not explain how the retailer-cost calculation works in practice; the provision it refers to is not included.
  • “Related to the facility” is not defined for deciding whether public financial support brings a venue within the bill.
  • The bill does not set out complaint, inspection or decision procedures. The supplied materials also do not give details of penalties or appeals.
  • The supplied text does not specify a start date. In any case, the bill failed and is not in effect.
  • The current law on unfair trade practices and the referenced cost calculation could not be verified because the relevant existing statutes were not supplied.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that public support for a stadium would come with a limit on food and drink prices charged inside it.
  • Using an existing retailer-cost calculation could give sellers and enforcers a shared basis for applying the price limit.
  • Treating violations as unfair trade practices would connect the new rule to an existing area of consumer law.

Case against#

  • The 20% ceiling is based on retailer cost. It may not account for other costs of selling at a stadium; the bill does not explain how those costs should affect prices.
  • The bill does not spell out how the cost calculation would apply to different products or sales arrangements.
  • The definition of public support covers many forms of assistance, including tax benefits and tax-exempt bond proceeds. The bill does not explain how to determine whether support is sufficiently related to a facility.
  • The bill creates a price rule but does not set out its own procedures for checking compliance or resolving disputes.