Expand sexual assault rules for officers

Summary#

Wisconsin Assembly Bill 1171 would amend the state’s sexual-assault law; it did not become law because it failed. Its apparent goal is to extend the existing rule against sexual contact or intercourse by a law enforcement officer to more people the officer encounters through work; the supplied material does not state a broader goal.

  • The bill would add people an officer knows are victims, witnesses, or suspects in any open criminal investigation.
  • It would also add anyone the officer contacts while carrying out official duties.
  • The conduct would be second-degree sexual assault, as it is for the existing categories. The bill says consent is not an issue under this part of the law.
  • The bill would make these new offenses subject to an existing provision that can require sex-offender registration if a judge finds registration is in the interest of public protection. Registration would not be automatic under that provision.

What it means for you#

  • Law enforcement officers: If the bill had become law, sexual contact or intercourse with a person in one of the added categories would fall under the second-degree sexual-assault prohibition. The bill does not make this a law because it failed.
  • People encountered by officers: The added categories would include victims, witnesses, and suspects the officer knows are part of an open criminal investigation, and people the officer contacts while carrying out official duties.
  • People already detained or in custody: The existing rule would remain. The bill text says it applies whether custody is lawful or unlawful and whether detention or custody is actual or constructive.
  • People subject to a case under this rule: The bill states that consent is not an issue. The supplied material does not give the full penalty range for a Class C felony.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives no estimate of public spending, court or enforcement costs, or other costs.
  • It contains no appropriation, fee, or fine amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “contacts in the exercise” of official duties, or explain how broad that category is.
  • It does not specify how “open criminal investigation” is determined or how long an investigation must remain open.
  • The supplied material does not give the full penalty range for second-degree sexual assault.
  • Sex-offender registration would depend on the existing provision and a judge’s finding; the supplied material does not explain how that finding would be made in these cases.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an officer’s work-related contact can create a power imbalance beyond formal detention or custody.
  • Extending the rule to known victims, witnesses, and suspects could address sexual contact or intercourse in the course of an open investigation, even when a person is not detained.
  • Including other people contacted in official duties could cover work-related encounters that do not fit the existing custody categories.

Case against#

  • The category covering anyone an officer contacts in official duties is broad, and the bill does not define its limits.
  • The bill does not explain how the rule would apply to different kinds of work-related contact, which could leave uncertainty about its reach.
  • The bill would apply the existing second-degree sexual-assault offense and its consent rule to the added categories; the supplied material does not explain how those provisions would apply in specific situations.