Pregnancy centers would require health data authorizations

Summary#

SB 1119 would have created a new section of Wisconsin law on certain pregnancy centers’ handling of health information; it would not have amended an existing Act. Its stated goal was to protect pregnant individuals’ information. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • The bill would have barred an “unregulated pregnancy center” from disclosing a person’s nonpublic personal health information without that person’s authorization, subject to listed exceptions.
  • It would have required a written or electronic authorization with specified information, including who may receive the information and how it may be used. Before getting authorization, the center would have had to say verbally that it is not covered by federal HIPAA privacy regulations.
  • An authorization could last no more than 24 months. A person could revoke it, though a center could rely on it for actions taken before receiving notice of revocation. Centers would have had to keep authorizations and revocations for six years.
  • Centers could not unfairly discriminate against someone for refusing authorization. Centers holding computerized information would have had to notify affected people after determining that a breach occurred, if their information was or was reasonably believed to have been accessed and acquired by an unauthorized person.
  • Violations would count as unfair and deceptive trade practices under Wisconsin law. The bill does not itself specify a fine amount.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking services: If the bill had become law, a covered center generally would have needed your authorization to disclose identifiable health information about you. The bill regulates disclosure; it does not set general rules for collecting or using information.
  • People who refuse or revoke authorization: A center could not unfairly discriminate against you for refusing. You could revoke authorization, but not undo actions the center took in reliance on it before receiving notice.
  • Pregnancy centers: The requirements would apply to centers that meet the bill’s definition of an “unregulated pregnancy center.” That definition excludes centers that provide or refer clients for abortions or emergency contraception and centers covered by medical privacy laws. A “pregnancy services center” would include certain facilities whose primary purpose is serving people who are or may be pregnant and that offer specified services or have the appearance of a medical facility.
  • People whose information is breached: A covered center with computerized nonpublic personal health information would have to give notice when the bill’s breach conditions are met. The bill does not set a notice deadline.
  • General public: The bill would not ban pregnancy centers or directly change what services they may provide. It did not become law.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • Centers would have had to handle authorizations, keep records for six years, and provide required breach notices. The bill gives no estimate of these costs or any required staffing.
  • The bill identifies violations as unfair and deceptive trade practices but does not state the amount of any penalty.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “unfairly discriminate” or explain how that rule would be applied.
  • It does not set out a process for handling authorizations, revocations, or breach notices, or a deadline for breach notice.
  • The bill allows disclosure in specified legal and law-enforcement circumstances. It does not explain how centers should handle requests that do not clearly fit those exceptions.
  • The materials do not include the current text of the laws the bill references. I could not verify how its requirements would interact with existing privacy, data-breach, or trade-practice law, or what penalties may apply under the trade-practice law.
  • The bill’s definition depends in part on whether a center is covered by medical privacy laws, but the bill does not explain how that status would be determined.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would require a person’s authorization before many disclosures of sensitive, identifiable health information by centers not covered by medical privacy laws.
  • Requiring the authorization to name the kinds of information, recipients, and uses could give people clearer information about a planned disclosure.
  • The breach-notice duty could alert people whose information may have been accessed and acquired without authorization.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the exceptions permit disclosures without authorization in several legal and law-enforcement circumstances, including cooperation based on a center’s reasonable, good-faith belief that conduct may violate law.
  • The bill does not set a deadline for breach notices or provide detailed procedures for authorizations, revocations, or deciding whether information is covered.
  • The bill would impose recordkeeping and notice duties on covered centers, but the available material gives no cost estimate or detail about how violations would be handled.