Nurses could refuse unsafe shifts

Summary#

SB-1115, titled “Minimum nurse staffing ratios in hospitals, registered nurses’ right to refuse a work assignment, prohibiting mandatory overtime for registered nurses, and providing a penalty,” would create new state-law duties and protections and amend existing employment-discrimination provisions. Its stated goal is to set hospital nurse staffing standards and protect nurses who refuse unsafe work or certain overtime. The bill failed, so these proposed changes did not take effect.

  • Hospitals would have to submit yearly staffing plans to the Department of Health Services (DHS). Plans would need approval from a hospital committee whose members are mostly nonsupervisory registered nurses who provide direct care.
  • Plans would have to set maximum patient loads for each registered nurse, at all times during each shift: emergency 4 patients; intensive care emergency 2; trauma emergency 2 trauma patients; intensive care 2; progressive care 3; telemetry 4; medical-surgical 5; pediatric 4; operating room 1; postanesthesia care 2; oncology 5; orthopedic 5; psychiatry 6; labor, postpartum, and nursery obstetrics 4 each; neonatal intensive care 2.
  • Hospitals would have to post plans in each unit; DHS would post them online. Hospitals would also have to keep shift-by-shift staffing records for at least three years and make them available to DHS and, on request, staff, unions, patients, and the public.
  • A nurse could refuse an assignment or other work activity if, in good faith and professional judgment, the nurse is not prepared to do it without risking patient safety or the nurse’s license. A hospital could not retaliate or report the nurse to a state disciplinary body for that refusal; the nurse or a representative could sue.
  • Hospitals generally could not require registered nurses to work overtime. Exceptions include certain patient-safety situations, ongoing surgery, critical care until another scheduled nurse takes over, declared public-health emergencies, and adverse weather, catastrophe, or widespread illness. Before requiring overtime under an exception, the hospital would have to make a good-faith effort to fill the hours voluntarily.
  • DHS could impose a $25,000 penalty for a late staffing plan. For failure to submit or follow a corrective action plan, a hospital could face $5,000 per day. DWD would handle complaints about retaliation for refusing overtime.

What it means for you#

  • Registered nurses: The bill would give you a stated right to refuse certain unsafe assignments and protect you from specified retaliation. You could also refuse mandatory overtime if you believed in good faith that the hospital had not made a good-faith effort to find voluntary coverage. Those protections would have limits, including the overtime exceptions.
  • Hospitals: You would have to create and submit staffing plans, meet the listed patient-load limits, keep and share staffing records, and follow corrective plans after certain violations. The bill does not set out a process for staffing-plan applications or approvals by DHS.
  • Patients and the public: You could request hospital staffing records, and staffing plans and violation information would be posted publicly. The bill does not create a service for patients to request a particular nurse or staffing level beyond the listed limits.
  • Nurses covered by inconsistent collective bargaining agreements: The bill’s rules would first apply when the agreement expires or is extended, modified, or renewed, whichever comes first.
  • Current law: The supplied Legislative Reference Bureau analysis says current law generally requires overtime pay for covered hourly employees who work more than 40 hours a week, but does not generally prohibit employers from requiring overtime. The current parent statutes were not supplied, so other comparisons with current law could not be verified.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied materials.

  • Hospitals would have to provide staffing-plan and record-keeping work, but the materials give no staffing or compliance cost estimate.
  • The bill sets penalties of $25,000 for a late plan and up to $5,000 per day for failure to submit or follow a corrective plan. DHS could reduce the latter penalty after the hospital follows an approved corrective plan for 90 days.
  • The bill does not state how much public agencies’ added work would cost.

What is unclear#

  • DHS would set the deadline for staffing plans; the bill does not specify that date.
  • The bill does not explain how the ratios would apply to units that combine or do not fit the listed unit types.
  • It requires plans to include a hospital’s internal review process and refers to annual review in its enforcement provisions, but does not spell out the review process or its standards.
  • The bill does not set out detailed investigation rules, decision timelines, or an appeal process for hospital staffing violations.
  • The fiscal estimate is referred to but not included. The cost to hospitals, DHS, and DWD is therefore unknown.
  • How these requirements would interact with other existing staffing rules or programs could not be verified from the supplied materials.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that fixed patient-load limits would give hospitals and nurses clear minimum staffing standards, rather than leaving each hospital to set its own limits.
  • Having direct-care nurses make up most of the staffing committee could bring frontline experience into hospital plans.
  • Public plans and shift-by-shift records could make staffing levels easier for staff, patients, and the public to check.
  • The refusal and overtime protections could help nurses avoid work they believe would put patients at risk or jeopardize their license.

Case against#

  • The bill sets the same listed limits for each unit type but does not explain how to handle units or situations that do not fit those categories.
  • Hospitals would have to meet the ratios and maintain records, but the materials do not estimate the costs or explain how hospitals would manage staffing shortages while meeting the limits.
  • The overtime exceptions could permit required overtime in several broadly described situations, including adverse weather, catastrophe, or widespread illness; the bill does not define those terms.
  • The bill gives DHS a role in setting deadlines and requiring corrective plans, but leaves key review and appeal details unspecified.