Breastfeeding breaks would be required

Summary#

SB 1131 would have created a new Wisconsin law and amended existing employment and labor statutes. It would have required employers to provide break time and facilities for employees breastfeeding a child under one year old; its stated goal was to set these protections in state law. The bill failed and is not law.

  • Employers with at least one employee, including state and local governments, would have had to provide reasonable break time when needed, a private place other than a bathroom, and access to an electrical outlet, running water, and a refrigerator.
  • Employers with fewer than 50 employees permanently in Wisconsin could have avoided those break-time and facility requirements if they proved compliance would cause significant difficulty or expense.
  • Break time could have been unpaid if the employee was fully relieved from duty. But employers would have had to count it as paid time if the employee was not fully relieved, or when deciding eligibility for an employer health-care contribution based on hours worked.
  • Employers and other people would have been barred from interfering with the right or retaliating against employees for using or enforcing it. Employees could have filed complaints with the department; the department could have ordered remedies, including reinstatement, back pay, and attorney fees.
  • The bill’s analysis says federal law already requires break time and a private place for many nursing employees. The bill would have added state requirements, including utilities and refrigerator access, and would have applied state requirements to employers with at least one employee, subject to the bill’s small-employer hardship exception.

What it means for you#

  • Employees who are breastfeeding: If enacted, the bill would have provided these protections for expressing milk for a child under one year old. It would not have guaranteed paid breaks in every case.
  • Employers: They would have had to provide the listed break time and facilities unless they qualified for the hardship exception. They also could not have interfered with the right or retaliated against an employee for using or enforcing it.
  • Employees covered by a collective bargaining agreement: If the agreement had terms inconsistent with the bill, the protections would first have applied when the agreement expired or was extended, modified, or renewed, whichever came first.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it did not change current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • Employers could have faced costs for break time, facilities, utilities, and milk storage. The bill does not estimate those costs.
  • The department would have had to receive and process complaints. The bill does not estimate the staffing or public cost.
  • The bill says a state and local fiscal estimate would be printed with it, but that estimate is not included here. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the Wisconsin statutes being amended, so it is not possible to verify what state protections already existed or how much of the bill would have been new.
  • The bill does not define “reasonable” break time or “undue hardship.”
  • It refers complaints to the existing process for employment discrimination complaints, but the supplied material does not include the rules and timelines for that process.
  • The bill does not explain how employers would show undue hardship or how disputes about it would be decided.
  • The fiscal estimate mentioned in the bill analysis is not supplied.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make workplace accommodations for expressing breast milk explicit in state law, including access to water, electricity, and refrigeration.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that state protections would have applied broadly to employers with at least one employee, while allowing a hardship exception for smaller employers.
  • Complaint procedures and protection against retaliation could have given employees a way to enforce the rights.

Case against#

  • One concern is that employers would have faced new facility and operating requirements, but the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • The terms “reasonable” and “undue hardship” are not defined in the bill, which could leave important disputes to later interpretation.
  • It is unclear how the new state requirements would have interacted with existing Wisconsin protections and the federal requirements described in the bill analysis.