Retroactive denial limits for health claims

Summary#

SB 1147 would have created a new section of Wisconsin law limiting when an insurer could take back money already paid for a health insurance claim. The bill’s stated goal was to limit retroactive claim denials; it failed and did not become law.

  • Insurers could retroactively deny payment for a claim only within 12 months after first reimbursing it.
  • The limit would be 18 months if the claim involved coordination of benefits with another third-party payer, Medical Assistance, or Medicare. “Third-party payer” includes other insurance and specified public, cooperative, and contract-based health plans.
  • A retroactive denial would include requiring repayment, reducing other payments, or withholding or setting off future payments.
  • The time limits would not apply if the insurer denied payment because the claim information was fraudulent.
  • The limits would start applying to policy or plan years beginning on the bill’s effective date. For plans affected by a collective bargaining agreement, they would start later if the agreement were newly established, extended, modified, or renewed.

What it means for you#

  • People with health insurance: If the bill had become law, an insurer generally could not have taken back payment for a claim more than 12 months after first reimbursing it. The period would be 18 months for claims involving the specified other payers.
  • People whose claims involve fraud: The time limits would not protect a claim if the insurer denied payment because information submitted to support it was fraudulent.
  • Insurers: They would have had to follow these time limits when seeking to recover payments, including by reducing or withholding later payments.
  • People covered by a collective bargaining agreement: The limits might have started later for the affected plan, depending on when the agreement was next established, extended, modified, or renewed.
  • The bill would not have changed what health care services a policy covered or set rules for deciding an initial claim. The available material does not include the current law, so it is not possible to verify how these limits would have changed existing rules.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public or private costs.

  • The bill included no appropriation, tax, fee, or fine.
  • Insurers would have had to observe the new time limits, but the bill provided no estimate of any administrative cost or financial effect.

What is unclear#

  • The bill text supplied does not state an effective date.
  • It does not define “fraudulent” or explain how an insurer would establish that information was fraudulent.
  • It does not set out a process, timeline, or appeal for a retroactive denial.
  • The current law and the bill’s effect on existing rules could not be verified because the text of the law being amended was not supplied.
  • The bill does not explain how to calculate the time limit if there are multiple payments for a claim.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people could face repayment demands or reduced future payments long after an insurer first paid a claim.
  • Setting a deadline could give claimants more certainty about whether an insurer will seek to recover a payment.
  • The longer 18-month period for claims involving other payers, Medical Assistance, or Medicare allows more time for those claims than the general 12-month limit.

Case against#

  • One concern is that insurers could lose the ability to recover payments after the deadline, even if they later found an error that was not fraud.
  • The bill does not explain how coordination with another payer would be determined or how multiple payments would affect the deadline.
  • The fraud exception has no time limit, and the bill does not define fraud or provide a process for resolving disputes about it.