Curbing surprise medical bills for emergencies

Summary#

SB 1164, “Preventing surprise bills for emergency medical services and other items and services under health insurance policies and plans,” would amend Wisconsin law by creating new provisions in Chapter 609. Its goal is to limit surprise bills and protect continued care for some patients. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Covered network plans would have to cover emergency medical services without prior authorization and without denying coverage because the provider or facility is out of network.
  • For emergency care, and for other services from an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility, plans would have to limit patient cost sharing, count it toward in-network deductibles and out-of-pocket limits, and pay providers under the bill’s payment rules.
  • Providers could generally bill patients above the required cost-sharing amount for non-emergency services at an in-network facility only after giving specified notice and getting consent. Extra billing for listed ancillary services would be barred unless the insurance commissioner allowed it by rule.
  • Plans and providers could negotiate payment; if they did not agree, either side could use an independent dispute process set by the commissioner.
  • Plans would have to offer up to 90 days of continued in-network benefits to certain patients when a provider’s or facility’s contract ends, or until the patient is no longer a continuing care patient, if that happens sooner.

What it means for you#

  • People enrolled in covered plans: If enacted, the bill would apply to defined network plans, certain preferred provider plans, and self-insured governmental plans. The preferred provider plans covered are those with a provider network and different requirements for using out-of-network providers.
  • Patients receiving emergency care: The plan could not require prior authorization or deny coverage because the provider or facility was out of network. Patient cost sharing could not be higher than for in-network emergency care.
  • Patients receiving other services at an in-network facility: The protections would apply when the provider is out of network. A provider could seek more than the plan’s cost-sharing amount only after meeting the bill’s notice and consent rules. Consent could not cover unexpected urgent medical needs arising when care is provided.
  • Patients in ongoing care: The bill would require plans to notify eligible patients of the option to continue care and give them a chance to tell the plan they need it. The protection covers specified serious or complex conditions, inpatient care, scheduled non-elective surgery, pregnancy care, and terminal illness.
  • Current law: The materials do not include the current text of the amended statutes, so I could not verify which of these protections already exist or how the bill would change them.

Money#

The bill requires plan payments and staff work, but no cost estimate is included in the supplied materials.

  • Plans would have to pay providers under the bill’s out-of-network-rate formula and send an initial payment or denial notice within 30 days of receiving a bill.
  • The bill would give the insurance commissioner rulemaking duties, including setting the independent dispute process. No staffing or administrative cost estimate is provided.
  • In dispute resolution, the party whose proposed payment amount is not chosen would pay the process fees; if the parties settle, they would split those fees.
  • The bill’s text says it may require a social and financial impact report, but that report and a fiscal estimate were not supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s interaction with existing state and federal surprise-billing protections is not explained in the supplied materials.
  • The commissioner would set or clarify some payment terms and the dispute process. Those rules and procedures are not included.
  • The bill does not set out the steps, evidence, or deadlines for resolving a payment dispute beyond the negotiation and filing periods.
  • Some payment wording refers to a “participating” provider or facility where the surrounding provisions concern a nonparticipating provider. The materials do not explain this wording.
  • The bill’s start date would depend on publication; plans affected by inconsistent collective bargaining agreements would apply it later, when the agreement is newly established, extended, modified, or renewed.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect patients from being charged more because emergency care or certain services came from an out-of-network provider.
  • Requiring in-network cost-sharing treatment would make those costs count toward in-network deductibles and out-of-pocket limits.
  • Notice and consent rules could give patients a chance to learn that a provider is out of network and choose an in-network provider when one is available.
  • Continued-care protections could reduce disruption for patients receiving specified ongoing treatment when a provider’s or facility’s contract ends.

Case against#

  • The bill would require plans to pay providers under a formula, but the supplied materials do not show the likely effect on premiums, plan costs, or public spending.
  • Important payment and dispute details would be left to rules, so the bill alone does not show how disputes would be decided in practice.
  • The bill covers specified kinds of plans and services, not every health plan or every out-of-network bill; the reach of the protections may therefore be limited.
  • The bill does not explain how its rules would fit with protections already in force, making it hard to tell what additional protections it would provide.