Prior authorization transparency rules

Summary#

Wisconsin AB 1217, titled “Prior authorization transparency, exemptions from prior authorization requirements, and granting rule-making authority,” failed and did not become law. It would have created new sections of Wisconsin law and amended other statutes to make several kinds of health plans follow the new rules. Its stated goal was to increase transparency about prior authorization and allow exemptions for providers whose requests are often approved.

  • Health care plans would have to publish a public list of services requiring prior authorization, and make current requirements, restrictions, and clinical review criteria accessible to enrollees and providers.
  • Plans would have to give contracted providers at least 60 days’ written notice before new or changed prior authorization requirements take effect, and update posted information before implementing the change.
  • Clinical review criteria would have to meet listed standards, including being evidence-based, updated at least yearly, and based on nationally recognized, generally accepted standards.
  • Plans could not deny a claim for lack of prior authorization if that requirement was not in effect on the date of service. They also could not deny certain supplies or services as “incidental” to an associated service that was authorized or did not require authorization.
  • The insurance commissioner could make rules requiring plans to exempt qualifying providers from prior authorization for specified items or services. Plans would have to grant the exemption when a provider met the threshold set by rule.
  • The bill would extend these provisions to several kinds of plans, including certain state, local-government, school-district, and cooperative nonprofit plans.

What it means for you#

  • Enrollees: If enacted, you could view a plan’s list of services needing prior authorization without creating an account. The bill would also require plan requirements and clinical criteria to be accessible to enrollees. Because AB 1217 failed, it creates no such rights or requirements.
  • Providers: If enacted, contracted providers would receive at least 60 days’ notice of new or changed requirements. Providers could be exempted for specified items or services if they met a threshold set by the commissioner’s rules; the bill itself does not set that threshold.
  • Health plans and review organizations: Plans would have to post and update required information and follow the claim-denial limits. A contracted utilization review organization could host the posted information and conduct prior authorization reviews.
  • People covered by state, local-government, school-district, or cooperative nonprofit plans: The bill would have applied the new provisions to several of these plans, subject to the bill’s effective-date rules. The parent statutes are not supplied, so I could not verify how these plans are regulated under current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • The bill would require plans to provide notices, maintain and publish information, and meet clinical-review requirements. The cost of doing this is not stated.
  • The bill authorizes the commissioner to make rules but gives no staffing or implementation cost.
  • The bill provides no appropriation, fee, fine, or benefit payment.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the statutes being amended is not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which requirements would be new and which might already exist.
  • The bill leaves the exemption threshold, evaluation period, eligible items or services, and exemption process to the commissioner’s rules.
  • The bill refers to definitions in other statutes that are not supplied, so the full scope of “health care plan” and some covered plans cannot be verified here.
  • The bill does not set an appeal process or specific penalties for violations.
  • Most provisions would have started on the first day of the fourth month after publication. For certain plans affected by collective bargaining agreements, they would have started later in specified circumstances. As the bill failed, these dates did not take effect.

Case for#

  • A public list could make it easier for enrollees and providers to find out which services need prior authorization.
  • Advance notice and dated online information could help providers track when requirements change.
  • Evidence-based criteria, yearly review, and limits on denying claims for requirements not in effect could make plan decisions more consistent and predictable.
  • Exempting providers whose requests are approved at or above a set threshold could reduce repeat authorization requests for items or services covered by the exemption.

Case against#

  • Plans would face new notice, website, and review-criteria duties, but the bill gives no estimate of their cost.
  • The bill leaves key exemption details to future rules, so its effect would depend on thresholds, evaluation periods, and covered items or services the bill does not specify.
  • The exemption is based on past or expected approval rates; the bill does not explain how the rules would account for changes in a provider’s requests or circumstances.
  • The bill does not set an appeal process or penalties, leaving those parts of implementation unclear.