Right to counsel in eviction hearings

Summary#

Wisconsin SB 1165 would create an Office of Civil Legal Aid and a nine-member Civil Legal Aid Board, and amend state laws on eviction cases. Its stated goal is to provide residential tenants facing eviction a right to appointed counsel at public expense. The bill failed, so it did not create that right or office.

  • The board, whose members would be appointed by the state Supreme Court, would appoint the office’s director, approve its budget and set conflict-of-interest guidelines for attorney appointments.
  • The director would handle requests, decide whether tenants qualify, and appoint lawyers. The director could appoint counsel only if enough money is available, and must prioritize counties with the most evictions and people disproportionately at risk of eviction.
  • Tenants who do not waive the right would generally be referred for counsel, and the court would pause the eviction case while eligibility and appointment are decided. Tenants would keep possession during that stay.
  • Landlords would have to include information about the right to counsel in rental agreements or addenda and certain termination notices. Eviction summonses would also have to include a notice.
  • The bill would set lawyer payment rates, require reports on case loads and spending, and authorize six full-time state-funded positions.

What it means for you#

  • Residential tenants: The proposed right applies to tenants in residential eviction actions after their tenancy is terminated. To seek appointed counsel, a tenant would generally need to appear on the return date or contact the court clerk by then. A tenant could waive the right only knowingly and voluntarily with court acceptance. A tenant who does not request counsel and does not appear, or who hires their own lawyer, is presumed to have waived it.
  • Tenants facing eviction: A court would have to pause the case while the director decides eligibility and, if appropriate, appoints counsel. The pause would end if counsel is appointed, the tenant hires a lawyer, or the tenant waives the right. The bill does not provide appointed counsel for every kind of housing dispute.
  • Landlords: They would have to provide the required notices. The bill does not itself change rent, create a tenant benefit payment, or cancel an eviction claim.
  • Courts and clerks: They would have to provide or display information, refer tenants for appointment, and stay cases in the specified circumstances. A court could also appoint counsel at county expense on its own motion or at a tenant’s request.
  • Attorneys: Appointed lawyers would generally be paid $100 per hour for case work and, in specified travel situations, $50 per hour. The case-work rate would rise with inflation starting in 2027. Attorneys could appeal the director’s payment decisions.
  • Taxpayers: The bill would authorize state spending and positions, but the total amount is not specified in the supplied material.

Money#

The bill would authorize spending and six full-time positions, but no total cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • It would appropriate a “sum sufficient” for office operations and for implementing the counsel program, including promotion and advertising. That does not set a dollar limit in the bill.
  • It would authorize one director position and five other state-funded positions.
  • The bill sets appointed-attorney payment rates and reimburses board members for actual and necessary expenses. It does not provide a total estimate for these costs.
  • The board would have to report spending and projected costs quarterly; if funds may be insufficient, it must provide a plan to address the shortfall.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the referenced state and local fiscal estimate, so the likely total public cost is unknown.
  • The bill does not define “disproportionately at risk of eviction” or explain how the director would measure that priority.
  • The director may appoint counsel only when funds are sufficient, and appointment is also described as discretionary. How those limits would work alongside the stated right to counsel is unclear.
  • The bill does not set out an income test or other detailed eligibility rules, timelines for the director’s decision, or a way for tenants to appeal a denial.
  • The current statutes being amended were not supplied, so I could not verify which eviction procedures or tenant rights already exist and which changes would be new.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to help residential tenants obtain legal representation in eviction cases, rather than face those cases without a lawyer.
  • A dedicated office could provide a central way to receive requests, assess eligibility, and appoint counsel.
  • Notices in rental agreements, termination notices, and summonses could make tenants more aware of the proposed right.
  • Pausing a case while counsel is considered could give tenants time to seek representation before the eviction case proceeds.

Case against#

  • The bill states a right to counsel but also limits appointments to available funds and requires priorities. Some tenants who qualify could therefore wait or not receive an appointment.
  • The bill does not define a key priority term or give detailed rules for eligibility and decisions, leaving important choices to the director.
  • Stays would delay eviction proceedings while appointment decisions are made. The bill does not give a deadline for those decisions.
  • The bill authorizes open-ended spending and staff positions without a cost estimate in the supplied material, making the financial commitment hard to assess.