Self defense costs reimbursed, records expunged

Summary#

HB-287, “Protecting self-defense-reimbursement and amendments,” failed and did not become law. It would have amended Wyoming’s self-defense statutes and created rules requiring reimbursement of certain defense costs and expungement of records when a person’s case ended because they reasonably used defensive force. Its stated goal was to clarify self-defense, provide reimbursement, and require expungement.

  • The bill would have required the county where the person was prosecuted to reimburse all reasonable defense costs, including lost time, bail, attorney fees, and expungement costs.
  • It would have required courts to expunge records for qualifying cases. A person whose charges were dismissed or who was otherwise released could petition for expungement, with no filing fee.
  • It would have amended the self-defense rule to cover force used to prevent injury or loss to another person or to real or personal property. Deadly force would be included only when necessary to prevent imminent death or serious bodily injury to the person using it or another person.
  • It would have required judges deciding self-defense questions to consider specified questions. After a jury found a defendant not guilty based on self-defense, the jury would answer whether the person was protecting themself, family, or property, or aiding someone in specified circumstances.
  • The bill would have defined “expungement” as permanently destroying, deleting, or erasing records so they are permanently irretrievable. It would have included investigatory files of local, state, or federal criminal justice agencies.

What it means for you#

  • People charged with a crime: If your case ended because you reasonably used defensive force, the bill would have provided for reimbursement and expungement. For an acquittal, the jury would have to find that self-defense was the basis and determine eligibility for reimbursement; the court would set the award. People with dismissed charges or other qualifying releases could petition for reimbursement and expungement.
  • People seeking expungement: A petition would generally have to be filed within 180 days after arrest or dismissal, whichever was later. The district attorney or arresting law enforcement agency could object within 20 days; an objection would require a hearing. The state could appeal an expungement order.
  • Counties and courts: Counties would have had to pay qualifying reimbursement awards. Courts would have had to order expungement in qualifying cases and decide petitions and awards.
  • State and local agencies: The court would have sent notice of an expungement order to the state criminal investigation division and other agencies or local governments it had reason to believe held relevant records.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the existing statutes, so it does not show which parts of the self-defense wording or process would be new. The bill did not create a new front-line service, tax, or fee.

Money#

The bill would have required county spending, but no cost estimate is in the available material.

  • Counties would have had to reimburse all reasonable defense costs for eligible people, including lost time, bail, attorney fees, other defense expenses, and expungement costs.
  • The bill sets no dollar limit or method for calculating “reasonable” costs.
  • Expungement and reimbursement petitions would have had no filing fee.
  • The state and its political subdivisions would not have been liable for civil claims resulting from a prosecution expunged under the bill.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not show how the bill’s wording compares with current law.
  • It does not define “reasonable costs” or explain how lost time would be valued.
  • It does not explain what proof or decision process would establish that a dismissal or release happened because of reasonable self-defense.
  • It does not explain how a court order would ensure records held by federal agencies were permanently erased.
  • The bill’s text says its changes would take effect immediately after required steps for enactment, but the bill failed and has no effective date as law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent people who reasonably defended themselves from bearing all the financial costs of a prosecution that ended in their favor.
  • Requiring expungement could limit the lasting effects of arrest and prosecution records in cases covered by the bill.
  • A jury’s answers about whom or what the defendant was protecting could make the basis for a self-defense acquittal clearer.

Case against#

  • One concern is that counties would have to pay all reasonable costs, but the bill sets no cap or clear method for calculating them.
  • The bill does not clearly explain how courts would determine that a dismissal or release was because of self-defense, or what evidence would be needed.
  • The bill calls for records to be permanently erased, including files held by federal agencies, but does not explain how a Wyoming court would carry out or verify that result.
  • A possible trade-off is that the bill would bar civil liability for the state and its political subdivisions resulting from an expunged prosecution.