Banks boycotting energy could lose government contracts

Summary#

HB 291, “Financial institution discrimination,” failed and did not become law. It would have created a new article of Wyoming law and amended an existing definition in Wyoming Statutes; the goal was to identify financial institutions that boycott energy companies and restrict their state banking contracts.

  • The secretary of state would have had to prepare and maintain a list. The Board of Deposits would have had to vote to approve it before it was publicly posted.
  • A financial institution would have received notice at least 45 days before listing and 30 days after receiving notice to show it was not boycotting energy companies. It could be removed if it showed it had stopped all such activity.
  • The state treasurer and state auditor would have had to refuse new or renewed banking contracts with institutions on the posted list. Contracts would also have had to require the institution not to boycott energy companies during the contract.
  • The bill would have added a new meaning of “discriminate” to an existing statutory definition: taking action intended to penalize a company, harm it economically, or limit commercial relations with it. The current text of that existing law was not supplied, so the full effect of this amendment cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • State government: If enacted, the secretary of state would have had to run the list process. The state treasurer and state auditor would have had to follow the contract restrictions.
  • Financial institutions: A listed institution could not have entered into or renewed a covered banking contract with the state. The bill’s definition of a banking contract includes services to the state or a political subdivision.
  • Energy companies and the public: The bill would not have changed consumer deposits or said that a listed institution was financially unsafe. It expressly required the list to say that listing was not a warning about the institution’s condition or deposit risk.
  • Current law: Because the bill failed, these proposed requirements did not take effect. The parent law was not supplied, so what rules already apply cannot be verified.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would have required the secretary of state to prepare, maintain, and update the list, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • It includes no appropriation, fee, fine, or other specified payment.

What is unclear#

  • “Energy company” is not defined in the supplied bill text. The bill defines “company” and describes fossil-fuel activities, but does not state exactly which entities count as energy companies.
  • “Discriminate” and “financial institution” rely on definitions in existing law, which was not supplied. The bill’s full effect on those definitions cannot be checked.
  • The bill does not set out a hearing, appeal, or detailed decision process for institutions challenging a listing.
  • It does not specify a standard of proof for deciding whether an institution is boycotting energy companies.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let Wyoming direct state banking business away from institutions that discriminate against energy companies.
  • A public list and a contract condition could give the state a consistent way to apply that policy to its banking contracts.
  • Notice and a chance to respond before listing could help prevent an institution from being listed without first being told why.
  • The bill limits what evidence can support a listing by barring reliance solely on energy-company complaints or media reports.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key terms and the decision standard unclear, which could make it hard for institutions to know what conduct would lead to listing.
  • The secretary of state would decide whether to list an institution, but the bill does not provide a formal hearing or appeal process.
  • A listing would require the state treasurer and auditor to reject or not renew banking contracts, which could limit the state’s choices of banking providers.
  • The bill gives no estimate of the cost of running the list or changing state banking contracts.