Public entities immune from firearm torts

Summary#

Wyoming HB 302, “Governmental immunity for use of firearms,” would amend two existing Wyoming statute sections, rather than create a new law or agency. Its stated aim is to clarify when government entities are not liable for tort claims tied to employees’ use or failure to use firearms. The bill failed, so it did not take effect.

  • Government entities would be immune from liability for tort claims tied to a public employee’s use or failure to use a firearm.
  • A public employee acting within the scope of their duty would be entitled to a defense paid for by the government entity, under rules in an existing statute.
  • A school district would be immune from liability for tort claims tied to an employee’s use or failure to use a firearm carried in accordance with the school-property statute.

What it means for you#

  • Government entities: If the bill had become law, they would have had the stated immunity for the covered tort claims.
  • Public employees: The bill would not itself give employees immunity from liability. It would entitle an employee acting within the scope of their duty to a government-paid defense.
  • School districts: The bill would give them the stated immunity when the firearm was carried in accordance with the school-property statute.
  • People bringing tort claims: The bill could prevent recovery from a government entity for claims covered by the immunity. The text does not say that it bars claims against employees.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it made no change to current law.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of the bill’s costs.

  • The bill would require a government entity to pay for a covered public employee’s defense, but gives no estimate of how often that would happen or what it would cost.
  • The bill states no specific appropriation, fee, fine, or savings.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the two amended statutes were not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be compared with current law or existing exceptions.
  • The bill does not define “firearm” or explain how broadly “related to” applies.
  • The rules for the government-paid defense are in another statutory subsection, which was not supplied.
  • The bill does not set out a process for handling claims or explain how its provisions would interact with other immunity rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit uncertainty about government liability for claims tied to employees’ firearm use or failure to use a firearm.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it protects government entities from tort liability in these situations while providing a defense for employees acting within their duties.
  • The separate school-district provision makes clear that its immunity applies only when the firearm is carried in accordance with the school-property statute.

Case against#

  • The immunity covers tort claims tied to both using and failing to use a firearm, and the bill does not state exceptions. This could limit people’s ability to recover from a government entity for harm connected to either action or inaction.
  • The phrase “related to” is not defined, leaving the reach of the immunity unclear.
  • The bill requires government-paid defense costs for covered employees but gives no estimate of those costs.