Bill would require independent cost analyses of rules

Summary#

HB-312, “Administrative rules-independent review and analysis,” would have amended Wyoming’s Administrative Procedure Act and created a regulatory review office inside the governor’s office. Its stated goal was to review agency rules and improve consistency and analysis; those are aims, not guaranteed results. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The governor would appoint the office’s director. The office would review each agency rule, conduct cost-benefit analyses, help coordinate rulemaking, and review all agencies’ rules at least once every five years.
  • Each agency would have to publish an annual regulatory plan and complete or arrange a cost-benefit analysis before adopting, changing, or repealing a rule subject to the bill.
  • The analysis would cover the rule’s need, alternatives, costs and benefits, effects on state revenue and spending, opportunity costs, sources, assumptions, and uncertainties.
  • A cost-benefit analysis could be omitted for an emergency rule only if the governor found an emergency existed after the review office had reviewed it.
  • The bill would authorize three full-time positions and appropriate $400,000 through June 30, 2026. It states an intent to include the positions and double the appropriation in the next biennium; it does not itself appropriate that future money.

What it means for you#

  • Agencies: Each would have to submit an annual plan by July 1, list anticipated rulemaking, describe planned efforts to streamline and review rules, and post the plan on its main website. Agencies would also have to make cost-benefit analyses available online.
  • People and businesses affected by proposed rules: They would be able to see the analysis. If someone objected to an analysis’s accuracy before final adoption, the agency would have to include a concise statement of the objection and its response with the final rules submitted for review.
  • The public: The review office would report each year to the governor, attorney general, and legislative management council. The report would identify analyses estimating an economic impact of at least $100,000 in Wyoming and rules recommended for repeal or sunset.
  • People and businesses generally: The bill would not itself impose a new fee, fine, tax, or direct service. Its proposed review process applies to rules with notice on or after July 1, 2025, but because the bill failed, that process did not take effect.

Money#

The bill would appropriate $400,000 from the general fund for three positions through June 30, 2026; no cost estimate for the analysis work is available.

  • Agencies would have to prepare or arrange analyses, but the bill gives no estimate of the resulting staff or other costs.
  • The review office could employ qualified staff subject to available funding. The bill authorizes three full-time positions through June 30, 2026.
  • The bill expresses an intent to double the appropriation in the next biennium, but does not make that future appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the existing Administrative Procedure Act, so what requirements already apply—and which parts of the bill would be new—could not be verified against current law.
  • The bill does not set a method for measuring costs and benefits or define key terms such as “burdensome” and “opportunity costs.”
  • It requires agencies to complete or arrange analyses and also directs the review office to conduct them. How that work would be divided is not specified.
  • The bill does not set a process for challenging an analysis, require an agency to change a rule after a review, or set a deadline for the review office to finish its work.
  • The office could recommend repeal or sunset of rules, but the bill would not automatically repeal or sunset them.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make agencies explain why they need rules and what costs and benefits they expect.
  • Publishing analyses and plans could give the public information about proposed rulemaking and agencies’ review work.
  • A review office inside the governor’s office could support consistency across agencies and help identify outdated or conflicting rules.
  • Regular reviews could help agencies find rules that may no longer fit current law or standards.

Case against#

  • The bill does not prescribe a common method for cost-benefit analyses. Agencies’ estimates could therefore be hard to compare or assess.
  • Requiring analyses for rule changes, plus review of all rules every five years, could add work and expense for agencies; the bill gives no estimate of those costs.
  • The office would have broad review and coordination duties, but the bill does not specify how it would resolve disagreements with agencies or ensure its recommendations are acted on.
  • The bill would require public disclosure of analyses and responses to objections, but it would not create a formal appeal or require changes when an analysis is disputed.