Limit on safety-rating requests proposed

Summary#

HB-168, “Experience ratings-amendments,” would create a restriction on requesting workers’ compensation experience ratings and amend Wyoming’s workers’ compensation statutes. Its stated goal is not provided beyond the bill’s provisions. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • It would prohibit requesting someone’s experience rating to determine that person’s employment safety record. It would also prohibit requesting a rating to obtain a contractor’s or supplier’s safety record for a construction project in Wyoming, whether or not they are based in Wyoming.
  • Those prohibitions would not apply to litigation or to actions by the workers’ compensation division related to operating the workers’ compensation system.
  • A new subsection would require the division to decide whether an injury is chargeable to an employer’s account within 15 days of an injury report, or within 45 days after requesting more information if that information is provided on time.
  • The new subsection would allow a qualifying employer to seek a redetermination within one year if new information shows that a third party primarily caused the injury. The employer must be current on premium payments and prove its case.
  • The bill would require the division to make rules for chargeability decisions. It would not impair contracts or agreements involving experience ratings made before July 1, 2026. The proposed effective date was July 1, 2026.
  • Although the bill’s title mentions penalties, the text supplied does not set out a fine or other penalty.

What it means for you#

  • Employers: The proposed timelines and redetermination process concern whether an injury is charged to an employer’s account for rating purposes. If the division finds a third party primarily caused the injury, the injury would not be charged to the employer’s account. The bill says such a decision is only for ratemaking and cannot be used as evidence in civil litigation about the injury.
  • Contractors, suppliers, and people requesting ratings: The bill would bar the specified requests for safety-record purposes, but not every request for an experience rating. It does not define a process for requests or explain how the prohibition would be enforced.
  • Workers: The text does not directly change workers’ compensation benefit eligibility or amounts.
  • Workers’ compensation division: It would have to meet the new decision deadlines and make rules. The bill text also includes provisions on experience-rating chargeability in an amended existing section, but without the current statute or amendment markup, it is not possible to tell which parts of that section would be new.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated cost or savings.

  • The bill would require division rulemaking and timely chargeability decisions, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • It would not set a fee, tax, or fine in the text supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the amended workers’ compensation statutes was not supplied, so the full change to the existing chargeability rules cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how the request prohibition would be enforced, or provide a penalty for violating it.
  • It does not define how to determine whether a request is “for the purpose” of getting a safety record.
  • The division’s rules, review process details, and how the deadlines would work in practice are not included.
  • The bill does not explain how the new request restrictions would interact with existing contracts or other uses of experience ratings.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an experience rating used to set workers’ compensation premiums should not be treated as an employer’s safety record. The bill states that the rating is based on past claims and is not a reflection of safety for employment purposes.
  • The decision deadlines could give employers a clearer timetable for determining whether an injury affects their account.
  • Allowing a limited redetermination when new information shows a third party primarily caused an injury could correct an earlier chargeability decision.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill bars certain requests without setting out an enforcement process or a stated penalty.
  • The bill does not explain how the division will meet the deadlines when information is missing or disputed, beyond allowing extra time after a request for information.
  • The new redetermination route depends on new information, a one-year limit, and the employer proving its case; the bill does not explain how those requirements will be applied.
  • The division would have added rulemaking and decision duties, but the bill provides no cost or staffing estimate.