Judicial elections would replace appointment system

Summary#

HJ-6, “Election of judges and justices,” proposed to amend the Wyoming Constitution. Its stated goal was to replace the current appointment-and-retention system with elections for judges and justices; the resolution failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Under the current system described in the bill, a judicial nominating commission sends three names to the governor for appointment, and judges later face retention votes. The proposal would remove the commission process and retention votes.
  • Justices and other statewide judges would be elected by voters statewide; district judges would be elected by voters in their districts. Elections would be at general elections and on nonpartisan ballots.
  • A judge or justice seeking another term would have to file a declaration of intent three to six months before the election. Other qualified people could also seek the office.
  • The proposal says judicial terms would be set by law. It does not itself give all judges a single, clearly stated term length.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming voters: If adopted, voters would choose among judicial candidates, rather than only deciding whether to retain an appointed judge. Statewide voters would choose statewide judges; district voters would choose district judges.
  • Judges and candidates: A sitting judge who wanted another term would have to stand for election. Other qualified candidates could seek the same office.
  • People needing a new judge: The text appears to replace appointment-based selection with election, but the supplied text does not clearly show how a vacancy would be handled before the next election.
  • Everyone: Because the resolution failed, it creates no new election, duty, or right.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution includes no appropriation or cost estimate.
  • It does not say whether or how much election administration costs would change.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text combines existing and proposed wording, making the exact vacancy process hard to verify. It is unclear whether an interim appointment would be allowed before the next general election.
  • The proposal says terms would be set by law but does not specify the full term lengths or other election rules.
  • It does not set out candidate qualifications beyond referring to “qualified” candidates, or explain how qualifications would be assessed.
  • It does not explain how the change would interact with other laws governing judicial elections.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give voters a direct choice about who holds judicial office.
  • A possible argument for the change is that an election lets voters choose a replacement when a judge’s term ends, instead of limiting them to a yes-or-no retention vote.
  • Nonpartisan ballots would keep party labels off the judicial ballot, as the bill describes it.

Case against#

  • The proposal would remove the judicial nominating commission’s role in selecting nominees, but does not explain what process would take its place for assessing candidates’ qualifications.
  • Voters would have to choose among judicial candidates; the bill does not provide information rules or other measures to help voters compare them.
  • The unclear vacancy language leaves open how an empty judicial seat would be filled before the next election.