Courts could review school funding formula

Summary#

SJ-8, “School funding-legislative and executive authority,” was a Wyoming Senate joint resolution proposing a constitutional amendment. It would require a formula for public-school operating costs, allow courts to review whether the formula complies with the constitution, and bar courts from reviewing the amount appropriated to fund it. Its stated goal is to specify those rules; the resolution failed, so it did not change the constitution.

  • The legislature would have to provide a formula for funding public-school operating costs and fund that formula by appropriation.
  • Courts could review the formula for constitutional compliance, but could not review the amount of the appropriation.
  • If the appropriation were too small to fund the formula’s spending, that spending would be reduced by a uniform percentage.

What it means for you#

  • Legislature: If the amendment had taken effect, it would have had to provide and fund the operating-cost formula.
  • Courts: They could review whether the formula meets constitutional requirements, but not the appropriation amount.
  • Public schools and the public: If the appropriation fell short, spending under the formula would be reduced by the same percentage. The resolution does not specify a funding amount or guarantee that funding would meet schools’ needs.
  • Everyone: Because SJ-8 failed, none of these proposed rules took effect.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The resolution specifies a formula and an appropriation, but gives no dollar amount or estimate of public cost.
  • It does not propose a tax, fee, or direct appropriation itself.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the Wyoming Constitution’s school-funding provision, so how much of the proposed wording would be new cannot be verified.
  • The resolution does not define “operating costs” or explain what the funding formula must include.
  • It does not explain how a uniform percentage reduction would be calculated or applied.
  • The resolution does not provide an implementation date or further rules for putting the formula into effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the amendment is that it would leave the formula open to constitutional review while reserving the decision about the appropriation amount to the legislature.
  • A uniform percentage reduction could apply the same cut across spending under the formula if the appropriation were insufficient.

Case against#

  • One concern is that courts could not review whether the appropriation amount was adequate, even if it left the formula’s spending short.
  • An across-the-board percentage reduction might not account for different needs among schools or districts; the resolution does not provide for exceptions.
  • The resolution does not define operating costs or set requirements for the formula, leaving important details unspecified.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1632273

    Passed31 members voted

    Failed Introduction 19-12-0-0-0

    FOR · 19AGAINST · 12

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    19For

    • Republican19

    12Against

    • Republican10
    • Democratic2