Judges elections would replace appointments

Summary#

HJ-6, “Election of judges and justices,” is a proposed amendment to the Wyoming Constitution, not a statute. It would replace appointment and retention voting with elections for judges and justices; its stated goal is to provide for their election. The resolution failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Under the process described in the bill’s ballot statement, a judicial nominating commission selects three qualified people for a vacancy and the governor appoints one; judges and justices later face retention votes. HJ-6 would repeal the commission provisions and retention requirement.
  • Voters would elect justices and judges at general elections. The electorate would be statewide for Supreme Court justices and other statewide judicial offices, and district-based for district judges.
  • District court judges would serve six-year terms. The text says terms for other courts are to be provided by law.
  • The proposal would use nonpartisan judicial ballots. It also appears to provide for election to fill vacancies at a general election, but the altered text does not clearly explain who serves in the meantime or exactly how those elections would work.
  • The proposed amendment would have needed approval by two-thirds of each house of the Legislature and then a majority of voters at an election to take effect. It failed before that process was completed.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming voters: If the amendment had taken effect, voters would choose judges and justices rather than decide whether appointed judges should be retained. The text assigns the statewide electorate or the relevant judicial district electorate, depending on the office.
  • Judicial candidates and judges: A sitting judge or justice seeking another term would have to file a declaration of intent within the stated filing period. The proposal also refers to other qualified people filing to seek office. The exact ballot format and how candidates would compete are unclear in the available text.
  • State government: The proposal would remove the judicial nominating commission’s role in selecting nominees and the governor’s role in appointing judges from its lists. The text appears to shift vacancy selection to voters at the next general election, but does not clearly set out interim arrangements.
  • Everyone: Because HJ-6 failed, none of these changes took effect.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The materials give no estimate of election, staffing, or other public costs, and do not specify who would pay any added costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text contains overlapping edits that make parts of the election and vacancy rules difficult to read.
  • It does not clearly explain the ballot format, how multiple candidates would appear, or how a winner would be chosen.
  • It does not clearly say who would fill a vacancy until the next general election.
  • The text specifies a six-year term for district court judges but does not state the term lengths for Supreme Court justices and other judges; it says those are to be provided by law.
  • The available material does not explain how election rules, campaign requirements, or election administration would change.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that voters would choose judges and justices directly, rather than having the governor appoint from nominees selected by a commission.
  • Elections could give voters a choice among qualified candidates, rather than only a yes-or-no retention vote. The bill’s exact method for offering that choice is unclear.
  • The proposal would apply the election approach to statewide and district judicial offices, rather than keeping the appointment-and-retention process described in the ballot statement.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill replaces a commission’s screening role and gubernatorial appointments with elections, without explaining what safeguards would apply to the election process.
  • It is unclear how the proposal would handle vacancies between elections or how voters would choose among multiple candidates.
  • The materials give no cost estimate for holding elections under the new system.
  • The election process and terms for some judicial offices are left to other laws, so the constitutional amendment alone would not provide all the details.