Districts could be placed in educational bankruptcy

Summary#

SF-173, the proposed Wyoming Educational Bankruptcy Act, failed and is not law. It would have created a new process for courts to place some school districts under a trustee, and amended existing state rules on student assessments and teacher certification. The apparent goal was to improve student performance in districts that repeatedly fell below specified assessment thresholds.

  • Starting May 1, 2027, the state superintendent could ask a court to place a district in educational bankruptcy if it met the bill’s test-score thresholds in two of the last three school years (districts with more than 800 students) or three of the last four years (districts with 800 or fewer).
  • A parent or guardian of a public-school student could also petition, with written signatures from parents or guardians of at least 12.5% of the district’s students. The district would still have to meet the same test-score thresholds.
  • A court would hold a hearing and, if it found bankruptcy was in students’ best interests, appoint a trustee to manage the district. The trustee would have to remove the district superintendent and take management authority away from the elected school board; the trustee could also remove other administrators or principals.
  • A tribal business council could intervene and submit an improvement plan if at least half the district’s students were “Indian children” as defined in state law. The trustee and court would have to give the plan deference.
  • The bill would cap educational bankruptcy at six districts statewide, with no more than three districts placed in it per year. It also would limit changes to the statewide assessment system that could substantially affect results used for this process.
  • The state board could suspend, revoke, deny, or refuse to renew a teacher’s certificate for fraud, cheating, or unfair practices in helping students on the statewide assessment. A hearing would be required unless the teacher waived it.

What it means for you#

  • Parents and guardians: The bill would have allowed you to file a court petition if you had the required level of signed support. It did not require parents to file or create a process for students to petition.
  • School districts and boards: A district placed in bankruptcy would lose its board’s management authority; the board would become advisory. The trustee would have to seek input from the state superintendent and local board.
  • District superintendents, administrators, and principals: The trustee would have to remove the superintendent. The trustee could remove other administrators or principals.
  • Tribal business councils: For districts meeting the 50% threshold, the council would have a right to intervene and submit an improvement plan. The bill does not give the council control of the district.
  • Teachers: The state board could take certification action for the specified conduct involving assessment help. The bill does not make that action automatic.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill would have created court and trustee responsibilities, but it did not set out a specific tax, fee, or fine.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would have authorized courts to appoint trustees to manage districts, but gives no estimate for trustee pay, staffing, or other costs.
  • It does not specify a new funding source or an appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how trustees would be chosen, paid, or supported, or how long a district would usually remain under a trustee.
  • It sets assessment thresholds but does not explain how they would be applied where the wording could be read in more than one way, including the grade 10 threshold.
  • If fewer than 90% of students take an assessment, a court may count some nonparticipants as scoring basic or below basic. The bill gives no method for deciding how many.
  • The state superintendent would have to consider academic benefits and harms, cultural factors, and district improvement efforts, but the bill does not say how those factors would be weighed.
  • The bill refers to existing state laws on assessments and teacher certification, but the current versions of those laws were not supplied. I cannot verify how much of the amended wording would be new.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that repeated low assessment results could trigger a court-supervised change in district management rather than leaving management unchanged.
  • The superintendent would have to consider possible harms, cultural factors, and steps the district had already taken before deciding whether to petition.
  • The limits on how many districts could be placed in bankruptcy, and the criteria for release, could constrain how widely and how long the process was used.
  • The required tribal role in districts with at least 50% Indian children could give tribal leaders a formal way to put forward an improvement plan.

Case against#

  • One concern is that an appointed trustee would take management authority from the local board, while the bill does not set out trustee selection standards or a detailed plan for involving the community.
  • Assessment results would be the basis for a major change in district control. The bill does not fully explain how nonparticipation or some test-score thresholds would be handled.
  • The bill gives the trustee power to remove administrators and principals, but does not set out criteria for those decisions.
  • The process could require public resources for court proceedings and trustee management, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding source.