Tax power split limits local spending

Summary#

SJ-10, “Legislative and executive authority-taxation and spending,” is a proposed amendment to the Wyoming Constitution. It would create a new section reserving taxation and spending power to the people and the legislative and executive departments, with limited delegation allowed. Its stated goal is to set out which branches may control taxation and spending.

  • The legislature could delegate local taxing and spending power to political subdivisions (such as local governments), but only if the power is exercised by people whose elected terms are no longer than four years.
  • For debt authorized by the Constitution, the legislature could assign the executive branch the ministerial tasks of paying debt service and setting tax rates needed for that payment. Courts could enforce those duties.
  • The legislature would have to create a funding formula for public-school operating costs. Courts could review whether the formula complies with the Constitution.
  • Courts could not review the amount appropriated for that formula. If the appropriation were too small to fund the spending set by the formula, that spending would be cut by a uniform percentage.
  • The supplied status says the resolution failed in Committee of the Whole. It did not become law through this proposal.

What it means for you#

  • Taxpayers: The resolution would not itself change a tax rate, impose a fee, or set a spending amount.
  • Local governments: The legislature could delegate taxing and spending power to them, subject to the four-year elected-term limit. The resolution does not require the legislature to delegate that power.
  • Public schools and students: The legislature would have to set an operating-cost funding formula. If the appropriation did not cover the spending under that formula, the spending would be reduced by the same percentage.
  • Courts: They could review the formula for constitutional compliance and enforce specified debt-service duties. They could not review the amount appropriated for the school formula.
  • State government: The change would set constitutional limits and permissions for how taxing and spending authority may be delegated. The materials do not show how it would change current practice. The current Constitution was not supplied, so that comparison could not be verified.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied materials.

  • The resolution requires a school operating-cost formula and an appropriation to fund it, but gives no estimate of the appropriation or its effect on spending.
  • It provides no estimate of costs for state or local government, including any costs of creating or applying the formula.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define “operating costs” or explain what costs the school formula must include.
  • It does not set rules for how the formula must be developed, when it must be completed, or how often it must be updated.
  • It does not say how a court would review the formula or what would happen if a court found it unconstitutional.
  • It does not specify how uniform-percentage cuts would be applied across schools, programs, or other parts of the formula.
  • It does not explain which local officials would count as exercising delegated taxing and spending power.

Case for#

  • The amendment could make the constitutional division of taxing and spending authority more explicit.
  • Requiring elected officials with terms of no more than four years to exercise delegated local power could keep that authority with officials who face voters regularly.
  • A school funding formula subject to court review could provide a legal check on whether the formula meets constitutional requirements, while leaving the appropriation amount to the legislature.

Case against#

  • The legislature could set a formula that passes constitutional review but appropriate too little to fund it. Courts could not review the appropriation amount, and the result would be uniform-percentage cuts.
  • The resolution does not say what a constitutionally compliant school funding formula must contain, leaving important details to later decisions.
  • The four-year term limit could restrict which local officials may exercise taxing and spending authority delegated by the legislature.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1485815

    Defeated30 members voted

    COW:Failed 9-21-1-0-0

    AGAINST · 21FOR · 9

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    21Against

    • Republican19
    • Democratic2

    9For

    • Republican9

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1484498

    Passed5 members voted

    S03 - Revenue:Recommend Amend and Do Pass 3-2-0-0-0

    FOR · 3AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    3For

    • Republican3

    2Against

    • Republican2