Labels would show energy sources at charging stations

Summary#

HB-158, the “EV Charging Stations Transparency Act,” would create a new Wyoming law requiring labels at certain direct-current fast charging stations. Its stated goal is to identify the main energy resource categories used to supply electricity to those stations. The bill failed and is not law.

  • Operators of covered stations would have to display a clear, conspicuous label measuring 3 by 3 inches.
  • The label would identify the largest energy resource category used in the prior calendar year. If that category supplied less than half of the electricity, the label would list the two largest categories.
  • Covered stations include those supplied only by a public utility, and stations that use both on-site generation and utility electricity. The bill does not cover stations supplied only by on-site generation.
  • Utilities would have to provide the relevant category information to an operator upon request. The calculation would use the utility’s energy mix in the service area, not the mix for each individual meter.
  • Operators would have to update labels annually by March 31. Violating the requirement would be a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to $750.

What it means for you#

  • Charging-station operators: If a station falls within the bill’s coverage, its operator would have to obtain or determine the required category information, display the label, and update it each year.
  • Public utilities: On request, a utility supplying a covered station would have to provide the largest category, or the two largest if the bill’s 50% condition applies.
  • Drivers: A label would show energy resource categories, not the exact source of electricity used at that moment. The bill would not change charging prices or require stations to use a particular energy source.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not establish a public program or provide public funding.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost or the costs to operators and utilities.

  • The bill would require operators to provide and update labels, but gives no estimate of those costs.
  • Utilities would have to provide category information upon request, but the bill gives no estimate of staff or other costs.
  • The bill sets a maximum fine of $750; it does not estimate how many fines might be issued or how much revenue they might raise.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how an operator must calculate the share of electricity from on-site generation, or who verifies that calculation.
  • It does not explain how to choose the two largest categories when the largest category is below 50%, including for a station using both utility electricity and on-site generation.
  • The bill does not specify a process for checking labels, enforcing the requirement, or correcting a violation before a fine.
  • It does not explain how the rule applies to a station using electricity from a source other than a public utility or on-site generation.
  • The bill uses “public utility” as defined in another Wyoming law, but that definition is not included in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a label would give drivers information about the main energy resource categories behind electricity supplied to a covered fast-charging station.
  • Using the prior calendar year and the utility’s service-area mix gives operators a stated basis for the label, rather than requiring utilities to calculate a separate mix for each meter.
  • Requiring two categories when the largest is below 50% could make the label less likely to suggest that one category supplied most of the electricity when it did not.

Case against#

  • A label based on the prior year and a utility service-area mix may not show the mix used by a particular station at a particular time.
  • The bill does not explain how to calculate or verify the on-site share, which could make compliance uncertain for stations using both on-site and utility electricity.
  • Operators could face a misdemeanor fine of up to $750, while the bill does not set out a warning or correction process.
  • The bill’s coverage excludes stations supplied only by on-site generation, and its treatment of other supply arrangements is unclear.