Summary#
S. 2258, the Protecting Our Farms and Homes from China Act, would create a new federal law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal, as reflected in its title, is to protect farms and homes from China. The bill has been introduced and referred to a Senate committee; it is not law.
- Covered foreign entities could not acquire or lease any interest in U.S. agricultural land, and would have to give up existing ownership and lease interests within one year. They would have to sign a letter of intent to do so within 180 days.
- The bill defines covered foreign entities broadly. The definition includes China-incorporated corporations, entities acting for or affiliated with the Chinese government or Communist Party, entities they own or control, and some of their directors and senior officials.
- For agricultural land violations, the Agriculture Secretary must impose a fine of $100 per acre per day. Violators also face criminal penalties, and land owned in violation may be forfeited and sold at public auction.
- During a period of at least two years, covered foreign entities could not buy U.S. residential real estate and would have to give up existing ownership within one year. The President may extend the buying ban for additional two-year periods.
- The Commerce Secretary must impose a $1,000-per-day fine for each residential unit owned in violation. The Attorney General may enforce the law, including by seizing assets or seeking court orders.
- The bill requires an office in the Agriculture Department and one in the Commerce Department to monitor compliance and impose fines. It also makes noncompete agreements with employees of covered entities holding agricultural land ineffective.
What it means for you#
- Covered foreign entities: The bill would require them to stop acquiring or leasing agricultural land, give up existing agricultural and residential property by the deadlines, and could expose them to fines and other penalties. The residential ban is on purchases; the bill does not prohibit renting residential property.
- Employees of covered entities holding agricultural land: Their noncompete agreements with those entities would have no force or effect.
- Farmers, landowners, and real estate sellers: The bill does not require sellers to check a buyer’s status or set out a transaction-review process. How the restrictions would apply in a particular sale is not explained.
- People in the United States: The bill does not directly change the rights of people outside its definition of a covered foreign entity. The definition’s reach is unclear for some individuals and organizations.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided; No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost is included in the supplied materials.
- The bill requires two federal offices and regulations; it does not specify staffing levels or their cost.
- It sets fines of $100 per acre per day for agricultural-land violations and $1,000 per residential unit per day. The materials do not say how fine revenue would be used.
- No estimate is given for enforcement costs, or for any effects on property prices or government revenue.
What is unclear#
- “Affiliated with the Chinese Communist Party” and “performs activities on behalf of” are not defined. The bill does not explain how officials would determine who meets those tests.
- The bill does not set out notice, review, appeal, or transaction procedures, or explain how a person could establish they are not covered.
- The agricultural-land definition includes land used for food processing and some recently idle land. How officials would identify qualifying land is not explained.
- The residential purchase ban can be extended every two years, with no stated limit on the number of extensions. The bill does not explain how the ban applies to territories.
- The bill says a covered foreign entity may be imprisoned for up to five years, but does not explain how that penalty applies to an entity as opposed to an individual.
- No publicly available information is supplied about how these provisions would interact with existing federal or state restrictions.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would prevent entities tied to the Chinese government or Communist Party from acquiring or leasing U.S. farmland, including land used for food processing.
- The agricultural-land rules cover both new transactions and existing holdings, rather than only restricting future purchases.
- The residential ban is temporary at first, and the bill requires a report on its effects on the housing market and affordability.
Case against#
- One concern is that the definition of covered foreign entity could reach individuals and organizations whose connection to China’s government or Communist Party is not clearly defined.
- The bill requires existing owners to divest and sets daily fines, criminal penalties, and possible forfeiture, but does not spell out a process for resolving disputed cases.
- The President could extend the residential purchase ban every two years without a stated limit. The bill does not explain how extensions would be assessed.
- The bill requires new offices and enforcement work but provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.