Lawmakers urge return of federal lands

Summary#

HR-189, titled “Requesting The President Of The United States To Return To The State All Recreational Facilities On Hawaii Public Lands That Are No Longer Required For The Defense Of The United States, Including Fort Derussy And The Hale Koa Hotel, Pursuant To The Hawaii Admission Act, And As Further Required By Public Law 88-233,” is a Hawaii House resolution, not a law that itself transfers land. Its stated goal is to return federally held Hawaii lands that are no longer needed for defense to the State and public land trust.

  • It asks the President to decide that federal recreational facilities on Hawaii public lands—including Fort DeRussy and the Hale Koa Hotel—are no longer needed for defense and to order their conveyance to the State.
  • It asks for a review of all federally retained lands in Hawaii, including set-aside lands and lands under 65-year leases made in 1964 for one dollar per lease.
  • It calls for returned lands to enter the public land trust and for the State, with the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA), to develop a Fort DeRussy land-use plan focused on cultural restoration, shoreline access, trust revenue, and Native Hawaiian well-being.
  • It asks the Governor to work with federal officials and Hawaii’s congressional delegation, and asks the Attorney General to assess legal options if the federal government does not act voluntarily.
  • It asks the Public Land Trust Working Group to seek legislative funding for an appraisal of federally occupied crown and government lands, with results due before the 2027 legislative session.

What it means for you#

  • Hawaii residents and public land trust beneficiaries: The resolution would state the House’s position and request action. It would not itself transfer land, change public access, or alter how the facilities operate.
  • Native Hawaiians and OHA: The resolution calls for OHA’s partnership in a land-use plan if Fort DeRussy is returned. It does not specify how Native Hawaiians would take part in planning or decisions.
  • Federal government and facility users: The resolution asks the President to act, but does not itself require federal agencies to release land or change who can use the facilities. It names facilities including Bellows, Pililaau, Kilauea Military Camp, golf courses, beach cottages, and a marina.
  • State agencies: The resolution asks the Governor and Attorney General to take steps, and says the State and OHA shall develop a plan after land is returned. It does not set out a process, timetable, or funding for those tasks.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution asks the Working Group to seek legislative funding for an appraisal; it does not appropriate money.
  • It gives no estimate for the appraisal, staff time, legal work, or land-use planning.
  • It asserts that the federal government has not paid rent or certain taxes on these lands, but the resolution itself does not change taxes, impose rent, or award compensation.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the text of the Hawaii Admission Act or Public Law 88-233. Their current requirements—and whether they support the resolution’s description of a return process—cannot be verified here.
  • The resolution asks for a finding that recreational facilities are no longer needed for defense, while also requesting a broader review. It does not explain how the review would assess military need or handle disagreements.
  • It does not define “legitimate military defense purposes” or say which specific lands would qualify for return.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material explains the cost, timetable, oversight, or public participation process for the appraisal and proposed land-use plan.
  • The resolution’s claims that federal retention amounts to a taking and breach of trust are its stated legal position, not a court decision included in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s approach could be seen as using the land-return process it says is provided by federal law, rather than itself trying to transfer federally held land.
  • If some facilities are not needed for defense, returning them could make land available to the State and public land trust instead of reserving it for military-affiliated recreation.
  • The proposed Fort DeRussy plan identifies possible public purposes: cultural restoration, shoreline access, trust revenue, and betterment of Native Hawaiians.

Case against#

  • The resolution asks for a conclusion that recreational facilities are no longer needed for defense before it sets out how that need should be assessed.
  • It seeks action on a wide range of different lands and facilities, but does not provide criteria for deciding which should be returned or how existing uses would be handled.
  • The resolution’s legal claims and claims about federal obligations are not established by the supplied material; if they are disputed, pursuing them could require further legal work.
  • The requested appraisal, legal review, and planning could require public resources, but the resolution provides no cost estimate or funding.