Senate to audit DOE positions

Summary#

SR-186 is a Hawaii Senate resolution, reported as signed into law. It requests an audit of the Department of Education (DOE); it does not amend an Act or itself change how positions or Complex Area Superintendents are managed. Its stated goal is to improve governance, efficiency, accountability, and leadership effectiveness.

  • The resolution requests that the Auditor examine how DOE establishes, classifies, and approves administrative and program positions, including the authority, criteria, paperwork, and Board of Education oversight involved.
  • It requests a look at position numbers and trends over the past ten years, including administrative positions compared with school-level or classroom positions.
  • The requested audit includes whether positions match legislative appropriations and policy goals, their costs, possible duplication or unclear reporting lines, and safeguards against unnecessary positions.
  • It also requests an examination of how DOE supervises and evaluates Complex Area Superintendents, including evaluation measures, consistency, and whether evaluations inform personnel decisions.
  • The Auditor is requested to report findings, recommendations, and any proposed legislation to the Legislature no later than 20 days before the 2027 regular session.

What it means for you#

  • DOE and the Board of Education: The resolution asks the Auditor to examine their position-approval and oversight processes. It does not itself change their authority or require them to change their practices.
  • Complex Area Superintendents: Their supervision and evaluation are included in the requested audit. The resolution does not itself change their duties, evaluations, or employment.
  • The Auditor: The resolution requests an audit and report. It does not say the Auditor must conduct them.
  • The Legislature and public: If the requested report is produced, it could provide findings and recommendations. The resolution does not require the Legislature or DOE to adopt them.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution gives no estimate for the audit, its staffing, or other related costs.
  • It asks the audit to assess the short- and long-term costs of newly created positions, including salaries, benefits, and associated costs.

What is unclear#

  • Whether the Auditor will conduct the requested audit and submit the report.
  • What resources or staff an audit would require; the resolution does not provide funding or a cost estimate.
  • How the Auditor would define “administrative and program positions” or decide which school systems are comparable.
  • What audit methods, evidence, or measures would be used to judge performance and evaluation quality.
  • Whether any recommendations would be acted on; the resolution does not require changes after the report.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that an independent audit could clarify how positions are created and approved, and whether those decisions match legislative funding and goals.
  • Comparing staffing trends, costs, and organizational structures could help identify duplication, unclear reporting, or weak controls.
  • Examining supervision and evaluation could show whether expectations for Complex Area Superintendents are clear and applied consistently.
  • The requested report could give lawmakers findings and recommendations before the 2027 session.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the resolution requests an audit but does not say the Auditor must conduct it, so the review and report are not assured by its wording.
  • The resolution does not provide funding or explain how the audit would be staffed.
  • The requested scope is broad, spanning ten years of position trends, costs, comparisons with other school systems, and leadership supervision and evaluation.
  • The resolution requests recommendations but does not require the Legislature or DOE to act on them.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1677180

    Passed4 members voted

    Senate Education: Passed, With Amendments

    FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    4For

    • Democratic3
    • Republican1

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.