Audits urged for campaign committees

Summary#

SR-164 is a Hawaii Senate resolution, not a bill that amends campaign finance law. It urges the Campaign Spending Commission to take steps toward candidate committees’ compliance; its stated goal is better compliance, not a guaranteed result. The resolution is introduced and referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, so it has not been adopted.

  • It urges the Commission to automatically audit candidate committees that spend more than $500,000 in an election period.
  • It urges the Commission to subsidize independent audits for committees that want them.
  • It urges the Commission to adopt rules defining a “substantially defective or deficient” campaign report, a term used in existing law.
  • It urges more frequent in-person training, including outside normal business hours, and other actions within the Commission’s power.

What it means for you#

  • Candidate committees: The resolution does not itself require audits, create a new reporting duty, or make committees pay for audits. If adopted, it would urge the Commission to audit committees above the spending threshold and offer subsidies to committees that choose independent audits.
  • Campaign volunteers: The resolution urges more frequent in-person training at times that may be easier to attend. It does not require volunteers to attend.
  • Campaign Spending Commission: The resolution urges the Commission to take the listed steps. It does not itself make those steps enforceable duties.
  • Public: The resolution does not change campaign finance limits, fines, or candidate eligibility.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of the proposed audit subsidies or other steps.

  • The resolution urges the Commission to subsidize independent audits, but gives no amount, funding source, or limit.
  • It gives no estimate for the cost of automatic audits, rule-making, or expanded training.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not say how often automatic audits would occur, how they would be carried out, or when the proposed steps would start.
  • It does not define “election period” for the $500,000 threshold or set rules for who qualifies for an audit subsidy.
  • It does not set a timeline for defining “substantially defective or deficient” reports.
  • The resolution’s statements about existing laws and the Commission’s past actions are not accompanied by the statutes or other records, so they cannot be checked against current law here.
  • The text names the recipient once as the “Campaign Finance Commission,” although it otherwise refers to the “Campaign Spending Commission.”

Case for#

  • The resolution says campaign finance laws have changed repeatedly since 2018 and that the Commission has not audited campaign accounts since then. If accurate, audits could help check whether reports match committees’ records.
  • Clear rules about defective reports could help committees understand what they must correct.
  • More training times could make it easier for volunteer-run committees to learn the reporting rules.
  • Subsidies could make independent audits more accessible to committees that want one.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not explain how audits or subsidies would be funded, so the cost and the amount of support available are unknown.
  • It does not set audit procedures, timelines, or safeguards for choosing committees to audit.
  • It urges several actions but does not require them or set a deadline, so the requested changes may not happen.
  • A spending threshold and optional subsidies may leave unclear how other committees would be checked or supported.