Auditor to audit building code council

Summary#

HR-164 is a House resolution, not a bill that amends an existing law. It asks the State Auditor to audit the Hawaii State Building Code Council; its stated goal is to assess whether the Council’s structure and work serve the public interest. The resolution would not itself change building codes, the Council’s powers, or how counties enforce codes.

  • The requested audit would examine the Council’s duties, makeup, past code updates, and the three-year code adoption cycle.
  • It would assess effects on consistency among counties, public safety, construction costs, permitting times, and housing production.
  • It would examine the Council’s inactivity since September 15, 2023, and whether counties collect enough permitting and related fees to help fund it.
  • It asks the Auditor to consider other governance and funding arrangements, including county-led code adoption and whether the Council should be changed or repealed.
  • The Auditor is asked to consult state and county offices, construction industry members, and others, then report findings, recommendations, and possible legislation before the 2027 Regular Session.

The supplied record lists the resolution as introduced and referred to the Finance Committee after a report was adopted; it is not shown as finally adopted.

What it means for you#

  • State Auditor: The resolution asks the Auditor to conduct the audit and submit a report. It does not itself impose a legal duty to do so.
  • Counties and named state offices: The Auditor is asked to consult them. The resolution does not require them to take part or change how they adopt or enforce building codes.
  • Construction industry and public: The audit could examine effects on building costs, permits, housing, safety, and consistency. The resolution does not change those things directly.

Money#

No cost estimate or funding amount is provided.

  • The resolution asks for an audit but does not include an appropriation or specify extra staff or funding.
  • It asks the Auditor to examine whether county permitting and related fees could fund some or all of the Council’s operations. It does not change those fees or require counties to pay.

What is unclear#

  • Whether the State Auditor will conduct the audit, and what staff, time, or funding would be available.
  • The resolution requests a report before the 2027 session but does not set a calendar date or say what happens if the report is late.
  • It does not set audit methods or standards for measuring public safety, consistency, efficiency, or effects on housing.
  • The resolution’s statements about inconsistency, burdens, and the Council’s inactivity are claims in its preamble; the audit’s findings are not yet available.
  • The current law governing the Council was not supplied, so its existing duties and the effect of the 2023 emergency proclamation could not be checked against the law.

Case for#

  • The audit could give lawmakers evidence about whether the Council’s work improves safety and consistency, and what costs or delays may be linked to code adoption.
  • Examining the three-year update cycle could help show whether it is practical for counties and the construction industry.
  • Comparing state-led and county-led options could help lawmakers assess who should guide and fund code adoption.
  • The requested consultation could bring county, state, and industry views into that assessment.

Case against#

  • An audit would not itself change code rules, reduce costs, speed permits, or alter the Council; those changes would require later action.
  • The resolution asks the Auditor to examine possible restructuring or repeal, but does not set criteria for choosing among those options.
  • The audit could be limited by missing staff, funding, data, or clear measures of the Council’s results; the resolution does not address those limits.
  • Its preamble presents concerns about the Council, but the resolution does not establish that those claims are true.