Study grid vulnerability to ground currents

Summary#

HR 404 is a Louisiana House resolution; it does not amend an existing law or create a new program. It asks the state to assess the electric grid’s vulnerability to ground-induced currents (GICs) and related harmonics, identify protection hardware, estimate costs, and explore funding. Its stated goal is to help protect the grid from GIC damage; the resolution has been introduced and is not yet adopted.

  • The requested assessment would use specified electrical models and standards, assume an electric field of 85 volts per kilometer and fully loaded transformers, and account for transformer age and condition.
  • The state is asked to identify hardware that could block GICs from entering the grid and estimate the total cost of using it.
  • The state is also asked to explore funding, including federal grants.
  • The resolution asks that copies be sent to the Louisiana Public Service Commission, the governor, Louisiana’s congressional delegation, the U.S. Secretary of Energy, and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.

What it means for you#

  • Electric utilities: The resolution requests an assessment of Louisiana’s grid. It does not impose a legally enforceable duty on utilities to assess their own grids or install protection hardware.
  • State agencies and officials: The resolution asks the state to assess vulnerabilities, identify hardware, estimate costs, and explore funding. It does not name an agency responsible for this work or set a deadline.
  • Residents and taxpayers: It does not directly change electricity rates, create a tax or fee, or provide a new service. Any effect on public spending or rates is unknown.
  • Grid protection: The resolution does not require utilities to buy or install equipment.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided.

  • The resolution asks the state to determine the total cost of GIC protection and explore possible funding, including federal grants.
  • It does not appropriate money, set a budget, or say who would pay for equipment or assessment work.

What is unclear#

  • Which state agency, if any, would lead or carry out the assessment.
  • Whether utilities would be asked to provide data, and how the assessment would be reviewed or reported.
  • When the assessment or cost estimate would be completed.
  • What hardware would be selected, how much it would cost, and whether utilities or the state would pay.
  • Whether the resolution’s technical assumptions would capture risks across all parts of the grid.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that assessing vulnerabilities could help the state identify where GICs might threaten grid equipment.
  • Specifying models, standards, and assumptions could give the assessment a common technical basis.
  • Estimating hardware costs and exploring grants could help decision-makers judge whether protection is feasible before committing to it.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not assign responsibility, set a deadline, or require a report, so the requested work may not be completed.
  • It asks the state to explore protection and funding but does not provide money or say who would pay.
  • The prescribed assumptions may not reflect every grid condition; the resolution does not explain how the assessment would address that.
  • It does not require utilities to install protection, so an assessment alone would not ensure changes to the grid.