Solid-waste financial assurance updated

Summary#

LD-2227, the An Act to Update Financial Assurance Requirements for Certain Solid Waste Facilities, is enacted and amends Maine’s solid-waste law, 38 MRSA §1310-Y. The law sets financial-assurance requirements for certain licensed facilities; its stated goal, as indicated by the title, is to update those requirements. The supplied text does not show which parts differ from the law that was in force before this amendment.

  • Covered facility owners or operators must show they can pay estimated costs for corrective action for known releases, and for closure and at least 30 years of postclosure care.
  • The text lists acceptable forms of assurance: a letter of credit, surety bond, escrow, reserve account, or irrevocable trust. It also lists certain federal financial tests and guarantees; municipal solid-waste disposal facilities may use mechanisms allowed by applicable federal rules.
  • The Department may replace part of the listed assurance with specified financial tests: qualifying debt ratings, liabilities-to-net-worth below 1.5, or a specified financial ratio above 0.10.
  • Covered licensees must review their assurance every year and update it as needed under department rules. The Department may require an independent third-party review of a proposed form.
  • Covered owners or operators must submit an annual sworn report of the year-end value of any escrow, trust, or reserve account. It is due by March 31 or another date set by the commissioner.

What it means for you#

  • Owners and operators of covered facilities: These requirements apply to privately owned, licensed solid-waste disposal facilities and to facilities licensed to process plastic waste through chemical plastic processing. They must provide financial assurance and meet the review and reporting duties.
  • Municipal facilities: The law exempts municipally owned or operated disposal facilities that accept only special waste, construction and demolition debris, land-clearing debris, or a combination of those wastes. It also exempts municipal disposal facilities licensed before June 16, 1993. Other municipal solid-waste disposal facilities may use financial-assurance mechanisms allowed by applicable federal rules.
  • The Department and board: The Department may consider more than one assurance form for a facility, may require an independent financial review, and may use the listed financial tests to replace part of the assurance. The board may change the 30-year postclosure period by rule, but the rule must be consistent with applicable federal rules.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The text does not directly change waste-service rules, household fees, or taxes.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Covered facilities must provide financial assurance, but no required amount or estimate of facility costs is given.
  • Annual reviews, reports, and any independent third-party review may involve costs; no figures are provided.
  • The supplied text does not state a public appropriation, tax, fee, fine, or expected savings.

What is unclear#

  • The prior version of §1310-Y was not supplied, so the available material does not show which requirements are new or how much of the law is unchanged.
  • The text does not give the detailed rules for calculating assurance amounts, reviewing and updating assurance, or deciding when the Department will require a third-party review.
  • It does not state the consequences for failing to provide assurance, update it, or submit the annual report.
  • The supplied text does not define “chemical plastic processing” or give an effective date.
  • No publicly available information is provided about the expected number of facilities affected or the cost of compliance.

Case for#

  • Financial assurance is intended to make funds or other financial backing available for cleanup of known releases and for facility closure and postclosure care.
  • Allowing several forms of assurance could let facilities meet the requirement in different ways.
  • Annual review and updates may help keep assurance aligned with a facility’s financial position and obligations.
  • The Department’s ability to require an independent review could help it assess whether a proposed form of assurance is adequate.

Case against#

  • The text does not specify how assurance amounts are calculated or what happens if a facility fails to meet the requirements, leaving important parts of implementation to other rules or decisions.
  • Some listed options rely on financial tests or guarantees rather than setting aside money in an account. The text does not explain how the Department will judge whether those options will provide funds when needed.
  • The Department may require an independent review, but the text does not say when it must do so or who pays for it.
  • The financial-assurance requirements and annual duties could add costs for covered facilities; the available material does not estimate them.