Data centers restricted in city districts

Summary#

SB 1000, Certificates of Public Convenience and Necessity and Construction of Data Centers, would amend Maryland’s Public Utilities Article and add a rule to the Real Property Article. Its stated goal is to extend some transmission-line construction requirements beyond overhead lines, change when the Public Service Commission (PSC) may waive a certificate, and restrict data-center construction in certain Baltimore City districts. It is at first reading and is not law.

  • For transmission lines designed to carry more than 69,000 volts, the bill would generally extend certificate, notice, hearing, and review requirements from overhead lines to transmission lines more broadly.
  • The PSC could waive the certificate requirement for construction related to an existing transmission line for good cause, but it must adopt regulations with specific criteria, including construction costs to ratepayers and environmental impacts.
  • The bill would remove the rule requiring the PSC to waive the certificate requirement for certain work on an existing overhead line when no new land rights or larger or higher structures are needed.
  • A person could complete work on an existing transmission line, including repairs, if needed to avoid an imminent safety hazard or reliability risk, and would have to report the work to the PSC within 30 days.
  • In Baltimore City, a person could not construct a defined data center in a development district subject to tax-increment repayment on outstanding bonds. The ban would not apply in the specified City-Wide Affordable Housing Development District.

What it means for you#

  • Transmission-line applicants and electric companies: For covered lines, a certificate from the PSC would generally be needed before construction or using condemnation (taking property through legal authority). The bill retains limits on who can receive a certificate: generally, an electric company or an applicant that is, or will be, regulated as a public utility.
  • Communities near proposed lines: The expanded process would include notice and public hearings for covered transmission lines. The PSC would have to consider factors including electric-system reliability, economics, environmental effects where applicable, and route alternatives for a new line.
  • People near airports: The bill’s airport restriction remains specific to overhead transmission lines. It does not extend that particular restriction to all transmission lines.
  • Baltimore City property owners and data-center builders: The construction ban would apply only in districts designated by Baltimore City ordinance and subject to tax-increment repayment on outstanding bonds. The bill does not ban data centers across Baltimore City or the state.
  • Local governments: The bill retains local authority over required local permits, which must be approved or denied within a reasonable time and under local laws where not preempted by state law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The PSC must adopt regulations for certificate waivers; the bill gives no estimate of the cost of doing so.
  • Possible effect, not an estimate: Extending the certificate process could add costs for some applicants. The bill does not quantify them or say how costs would be divided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out the PSC’s waiver rules; it directs the PSC to make them by regulation.
  • It does not explain how the PSC would apply “good cause” or how long certificate decisions would take.
  • The data-center definition uses a demand threshold of at least 5 megawatts and a load factor above 80%, including projected amounts, but the bill does not explain how those projections would be assessed.
  • The bill does not explain how to determine whether a development district is “subject to tax increment repayment on outstanding bonds.”
  • The current parent Act was not supplied. The bill’s markup shows changes from wording about overhead lines to wording about transmission lines, but the full current law could not be independently checked.

Case for#

  • Applying review and public-hearing requirements to more types of high-voltage transmission lines could give the PSC and affected communities a fuller chance to consider their costs and effects.
  • Requiring waiver criteria to address ratepayer costs and environmental impacts could make waiver decisions more specific and transparent.
  • The immediate safety and reliability exception allows necessary work on existing lines without waiting for a certificate, while requiring a report afterward.

Case against#

  • Extending certificate requirements could add process and expense for line projects that previously did not need the same review; the bill does not estimate those effects or set decision deadlines.
  • The bill removes a mandatory waiver for certain work on existing overhead lines, so the PSC could require a certificate in cases where the former rule required a waiver.
  • The Baltimore City data-center restriction depends on district and bond-repayment conditions that the bill does not explain in detail, which may make its practical reach hard to predict.