Data centers face tougher local review rules

Summary#

HB 6426, the Data Center Local Decision Protection Act, would create a new Michigan law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to set rules for local decisions about large-scale data centers. The bill is introduced, not law, and would take effect 90 days after enactment only if HB 6427 is also enacted.

  • A data-center application would not be administratively complete until it includes specified information and a public summary, and that information has been available for public review for at least 30 days.
  • Local governments would have to post submitted information within 30 days, except for information designated as proprietary or otherwise legally exempt.
  • Local governments could consider certain community impacts, require enforceable agreements tied to those impacts, and charge developers actual, reasonable application-review costs.
  • People challenging a local decision would have to meet new steps and a demanding court-review standard. Courts could award attorney fees to a local government in specified cases.
  • A person who materially misrepresents information could face civil fines of up to $10,000 for a first violation, $25,000 for a second, and $50,000 for a third or later violation.

What it means for you#

  • Data-center developers: For a project meeting the bill’s large-scale thresholds, an application would need information on energy, water, infrastructure, environmental impacts, ownership, affiliated entities and phases, plus a public summary. Developers would have to update materially changed information promptly and respond promptly to reasonable requests for additional community-impact information—or give a detailed written explanation if they cannot.
  • Local governments: Counties, townships, cities and villages would have to post the information they receive within 30 days, subject to the stated exceptions. They could consider cumulative effects on farmland, wetlands and natural resources, as well as applicable labor standards and workforce considerations. They could require enforceable agreements with requirements reasonably related to community impacts.
  • People seeking court review: A person aggrieved by a local decision would first have to exhaust available local remedies, give written notice of alleged procedural defects and allow at least 30 days to cure them, and meet existing legal deadlines. In court, the person would have to show by clear and convincing evidence that the decision meets one of the bill’s listed grounds for being set aside.
  • Public and nearby communities: The bill requires a public summary and public posting, but some submitted information could be withheld as proprietary or under other disclosure exemptions. It does not require a local government to approve or reject a project.
  • People who make material misrepresentations: The county prosecutor or state attorney general could bring an action to collect a civil fine. Collected fines would go to the state general fund.

Money#

No overall cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • Developers could be required to pay a local government’s actual, reasonable costs to review and process an application, including legal, engineering, environmental and public-safety analysis.
  • The bill does not specify public funding or staffing for the added local-government duties.
  • Civil fines are authorized, but the amount collected is unknown; fines would go to the state general fund. A court may award attorney fees to a local government in the listed circumstances.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s tie-bar makes its effect depend on HB 6427, whose text is not provided here; how the two bills would work together cannot be assessed.
  • Terms such as “reasonably projected,” “material change,” and “promptly” are not defined in the supplied text.
  • The bill does not set a process for deciding whether information is properly designated proprietary, or for resolving disputes about additional information requests.
  • It does not specify how local governments should assess whether an agreement’s requirements are reasonably related to project impacts.
  • No cost estimate, implementation funding, or detailed oversight and reporting rules are provided.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that local governments and the public would get more information before a large data-center decision, including on energy, water, ownership and environmental impacts.
  • Local governments could consider cumulative effects and make agreements addressing community impacts, rather than being limited to the information in an initial application.
  • Requiring developers to cover actual, reasonable review costs could reduce the burden on local budgets.
  • The bill sets steps and standards for court challenges, which could give local governments and applicants clearer rules for handling disputes.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the broad ability to designate information as proprietary could limit public access to details that matter to a local decision.
  • The clear-and-convincing-evidence standard, required local steps and possible attorney-fee awards could make court challenges harder or more costly for people aggrieved by a decision.
  • The bill gives local governments new options but does not spell out how they should apply terms such as “reasonably related,” which could lead to uncertainty or inconsistent decisions.
  • The added disclosure, response and application-review requirements could create costs or delays for developers and local governments; the available material does not estimate their scale.