Ballots would be hand counted with serial numbers

Summary#

CACR 31 is a proposed amendment to the New Hampshire Constitution, not a bill changing an existing statute. Its stated goal is to set statewide rules for ballot handling, counting, storage, access and audits; it also mentions compliance with a federal executive order. The House adopted a motion to declare it “Inexpedient to Legislate,” so it is not law and will not go to voters under this proposal.

  • It would require hand-counting and serial numbers on all ballots, with a matching dated, perforated tab that includes the polling place number and is kept by the voter as a receipt.
  • It would require local election officials to reconcile ballots, keep signed custody logs, preserve unused and voided ballots with their lot, and store ballots and election records for 60 months.
  • It would require secure, locked ballot storage under continuous electronic surveillance. Registered voters could view or record ballots and records by appointment, with one week’s notice and an election official present.
  • The Secretary of State would track numbered ballots, provide numbered ballots to municipalities, publish findings in non-election years, and randomly select at least two municipalities in each county for audits after each election.
  • It would limit polling places to 5,000 “lawful voters,” require voters on the current checklist to be randomly chosen as poll workers, and require annual training for moderators and clerks.
  • Despite the title’s reference to penalties, the proposed constitutional text sets out no penalties. It also does not specify what compliance with the named federal executive order would require.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: If adopted, you would receive a numbered ballot tab as a receipt. You could request to view or record ballots and election records during the 60-month retention period, but only by appointment, with one week’s notice, and accompanied by a local election official.
  • Voters selected as poll workers: The proposal says voters on the current checklist would be chosen at random. It does not explain how selection, notice, eligibility, or any exemption would work.
  • Local election officials and municipalities: Moderators and clerks would have to follow the new ballot-handling and storage rules and attend annual training. Municipalities could not print or copy serial-numbered ballots; the Secretary of State would provide them.
  • The Secretary of State: The office would have duties to track ballots, publish findings, provide ballots, and choose municipalities for audits. The proposal does not set out audit procedures.
  • Current law: The supplied material says these provisions are not currently in the state constitution, but does not include the current statutes or election rules. I could not verify which proposed requirements would be new compared with current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The proposal would require numbered ballots, secure storage with continuous electronic surveillance, annual training, ballot tracking, and audits. It gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • It authorizes the Secretary of State to provide ballots, but does not state how many staff, how much funding, or what equipment would be needed.

What is unclear#

  • “Lawful voters,” “ballot lot,” and some storage requirements are not defined.
  • The text says municipalities would be audited after each election, but also says an audit follows a request that the Secretary of State cannot refuse. How those provisions fit together is unclear. It does not explain how audits would be conducted or who may take part.
  • The proposal does not explain how serial numbers and voter-held receipts would be handled to protect ballot secrecy.
  • It does not say how voter access to records would be balanced with privacy, or what happens if records contain information that should not be public. It says election-day sign-off signatures cannot be redacted for any reason.
  • The proposal does not explain how the 5,000-voter polling-place limit would be applied, or what happens if a location exceeds it.
  • It does not say what provisions of the federal executive order must be followed. The text also sets no start date, implementation rules, or penalties.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the proposal is that numbered ballots, signed custody logs, and keeping unused and voided ballots with their lot could make ballot handling easier to track.
  • Public access to records and audits could give voters more ways to examine how ballots were handled.
  • Requiring annual training could help local officials follow consistent statewide procedures.
  • Keeping ballots and records for 60 months could preserve them for later review.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the proposal imposes detailed requirements without explaining how to carry them out, who pays, or how compliance would be checked.
  • Continuous surveillance, new storage rules, ballot tracking, hand counting, and audits could require equipment and staff, but the proposal provides no cost estimate or funding.
  • It is unclear how voter receipts, serial numbers, and public access would protect ballot secrecy and personal information.
  • The text leaves key rules unclear, including polling-place limits and audit procedures. It also refers to penalties without stating any.