Landfill permits paused for new rules

Summary#

HB 171, “Establishing a moratorium on the issuance of permits for new landfills,” would amend New Hampshire’s Solid Waste Management Act, RSA 149-M. It adds a moratorium section and schedules its repeal for July 1, 2028; the stated goal is to wait for new regulations, data, technologies, and policies before evaluating new landfill proposals. The bill has passed the House but is not yet law.

  • The Department of Environmental Services (DES) could accept applications for new landfill permits, check whether they are complete, and request information to complete them—but it could not go on to further evaluate or process them.
  • DES could not issue a permit to construct or operate a new landfill under the covered law while the moratorium is in effect.
  • The bill would not prohibit expansion or modification of a landfill on a site where a permitted RCRA Subtitle D landfill existed on December 1, 2022. The bill defines a site by parcel ownership on that date, including certain sites crossed by public utility easements.
  • The bill schedules repeal of RSA 149-M:9-a, the moratorium section, on July 1, 2028. On the text supplied, that appears to end this moratorium then.

What it means for you#

  • People or businesses seeking a new landfill permit: DES could accept an application and check whether it is complete, but could not continue evaluating or processing it or issue the permit while the moratorium applies.
  • Operators of existing landfills: The bill preserves the ability to expand or modify facilities only on qualifying sites with a permitted RCRA Subtitle D landfill that existed there by December 1, 2022.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The bill does not directly change waste fees, taxes, or individual rights. It does not set rules for how or when DES must develop the new regulations, data, technologies, or policies.
  • Current law: The text refers to an existing RSA 149-M:9-a, but the current law is not supplied. I cannot verify how much of this bill’s moratorium is new or how it changes the existing section.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied material gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • The bill assigns DES permit-related work, but does not state staffing levels or the cost of that work.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say what new regulations, data, technologies, or policies must be developed, who must develop them, or by when.
  • It does not set out how applications already filed would be handled.
  • The supplied text does not define “new landfill facility” or explain how DES would decide whether a proposal is covered.
  • The current text of RSA 149-M:9-a is not supplied, so the existing rules and the full change from current law cannot be verified.
  • The bill passed the House, but whether it will become law is not established by the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A pause could prevent DES from making permit decisions before the new regulations, data, technologies, and policies named in the bill are available.
  • Letting applicants submit materials and complete applications could preserve some preparation work, even though DES could not proceed to full evaluation during the moratorium.
  • The exception for qualifying existing landfill sites would allow their expansion or modification rather than applying the moratorium to every landfill project.

Case against#

  • The bill stops further evaluation of applications but does not set a schedule or requirements for producing the information and policies that the moratorium is meant to await.
  • People and businesses seeking permits for new landfills could face a delay until the scheduled repeal, without a process in the bill for earlier review.
  • The exception depends on a landfill’s presence, permit status, and site ownership on December 1, 2022. That could treat proposals differently based on those past conditions.