Public benefit screen for landfills

Summary#

HB 215-FN would amend New Hampshire’s solid-waste law, RSA 149-M. It would require the Department of Environmental Services (DES) to screen permit applications for public benefit before full technical review, and to find that privately owned landfill projects provide a net public benefit. The stated goal is to assess a project’s potential harms and benefits; the bill has passed the House but is not yet law.

  • For every solid-waste permit application, the applicant would have to show how the project meets the public-benefit criteria. DES would make an initial decision before completing its full technical review; it must deny an application if the project fails that screen.
  • For a proposed privately owned landfill, the assessment must compare potential harms with potential benefits. It must cover potential effects on health, property values, tourism, outdoor recreation and wildlife, as well as potential local economic and infrastructure benefits.
  • The landfill assessment would be done by an independent contractor for the host community and/or abutting municipalities, with the applicant paying. The applicant must offer at least three contractors; DES checks their qualifications and works with the applicant and host community to choose one. If they do not agree within 60 days, the commissioner chooses from the submitted list.
  • DES must consult, as needed, with transportation, business and economic affairs, and natural and cultural resources officials when reviewing the assessment.
  • A new landfill, or an expansion of an existing fully permitted RCRA Subtitle D landfill, would meet the bill’s capacity-need test if a state capacity shortfall is expected in at least half of the permit years. A new landfill could not accept waste before the first year a shortfall is expected.
  • The bill also says each project must be assessed on its own; benefits or harms from a related project cannot be used to change that project’s public-benefit evaluation.

The bill rewrites an existing public-benefit provision and changes other parts of RSA 149-M. The prior law’s full text was not supplied, so the available material does not show how much of the rewritten wording is new.

What it means for you#

  • Landfill applicants: You would face an early public-benefit screen. For a privately owned landfill, you would also pay for the independent assessment and submit the contractor list. Passing this screen would allow technical review to proceed; it would not itself grant a permit.
  • Host and abutting municipalities: The contractor would assess the project on behalf of the host community and/or abutting municipalities. The bill does not require a municipality to accept the project or give it a veto.
  • People living near a proposed landfill: The assessment must consider listed potential harms, including impacts from noise, odor, traffic and emissions. The bill does not require that every potential harm be prevented or compensated.
  • Other solid-waste permit applicants: You would have to demonstrate public benefit under the bill’s criteria, but the net-benefit assessment and its listed harms and benefits apply specifically to proposed privately owned landfills.
  • Taxpayers: The fiscal note says the bill has no state, county or local fiscal impact. The applicant-paid assessment could still create a cost for applicants.

Money#

The fiscal note estimates no impact on state, county or local spending or revenue; the bill gives no dollar estimate for the required assessment.

  • Applicants for privately owned landfill projects must pay for the independent contractor’s assessment.
  • The bill requires DES to perform the screening and review, but no staffing or administrative cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how DES should weigh different harms and benefits or what evidence is enough to find a “net public benefit.”
  • The bill uses “capacity shortfall” and refers to how capacity need is identified under existing law. The full current law was not supplied, so the definition and calculation could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set out a method for resolving disputes about the contractor’s qualifications, the assessment’s findings, or DES’s decision. Whether existing law supplies procedures is unclear.
  • It is unclear how the assessment and early screening would fit with other permit requirements or existing review processes.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material gives an estimate of the assessment’s cost or the time the new screening could take.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that DES would consider public need and a project’s potential effects before spending time on a full technical review.
  • An independent assessment could give municipalities and DES a structured look at both potential harms and benefits, rather than treating capacity or economic benefits alone as decisive.
  • The capacity test could tie new landfill capacity to periods when the state is expected to need it.
  • Consultation with relevant state departments could bring traffic, economic, tourism and natural-resource expertise into the review.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not specify how harms and benefits should be measured or compared, leaving important parts of the decision to DES and the contractor.
  • Applicants would pay for the assessment, while the bill does not state its likely cost or how contractor disagreements would be handled beyond the 60-day selection rule.
  • The bill makes public benefit an early gate: a project that fails it must be denied before full technical review. The bill does not explain how that decision can be challenged.
  • Assessing each project alone could prevent benefits or harms linked to related projects from affecting its public-benefit evaluation.