Renewable standard overhaul shifts solar

Summary#

HB 219 amends New Hampshire’s existing Electric Renewable Portfolio Standard law, RSA 362-F; it does not create a new law or agency. Its stated goal is to change the minimum renewable-energy requirements for electricity providers. The bill has passed the House but is not yet law; it would take effect July 1, 2027.

  • It removes Class II from the renewable portfolio standards and moves solar electricity into Class I. It also excludes wind energy required by government procurement from Class I.
  • Providers would still have to meet the listed standards with renewable energy certificates (credits for qualifying renewable energy) or make payments to the Renewable Energy Fund instead. The table sets the 2025-and-later standards at 15% for Class I, 8% for Class III and 1.5% for Class IV.
  • The bill reduces the share of the Class I requirement that must be met with certificates for useful thermal energy (renewable heat): the share becomes 1.7% starting August 1, 2025.
  • The Department of Energy would use fixed payment rates: $42 for Class I, except $30 for the thermal-energy portion, $42 for Class III and $37 for Class IV. The bill also changes how customer-sited Class I systems are estimated for certificate credits.
  • The Department of Energy would use remaining fund money for thermal and electrical renewable-energy initiatives and offshore-wind initiatives, including the named offshore-wind office. The bill does not create that office.

What it means for you#

  • Electricity providers: They would still have to meet the applicable renewable-energy standards or make payments instead. Class II would no longer be a separate standard. The bill does not set a new process for providers to apply for certificates or challenge decisions.
  • Renewable-energy projects: The bill changes which solar and wind generation can count in the classes listed. The text does not explain how existing projects or certificates would be treated during the change.
  • Households: The bill does not directly change household eligibility for rebates or grants, or set household electricity rates. Any effect on bills is uncertain.
  • Department of Energy: It must calculate and publish estimated certificate credits for certain customer-sited Class I systems. If there is no adopted state operating budget, it must timely seek Fiscal Committee approval to keep using fund money for renewable-energy rebate and grant programs.
  • Taxpayers and public agencies: The bill does not create a new tax or fee. The fiscal note estimates possible savings on electricity costs for the state and local governments.

Money#

The fiscal note estimates about $1.2 million less in annual Renewable Energy Fund revenue starting in fiscal year 2028, and about $12,000 in annual state electricity-cost savings.

  • The fiscal note says the fund revenue decrease reflects lower alternative compliance payments, mainly from reducing the thermal-energy requirement.
  • The fund’s spending is also estimated to fall by about $1.2 million a year; this is a reduction in available fund spending, not a new appropriation.
  • State electricity savings depend on utilities passing lower costs through. Savings on electricity bought from competitive suppliers are unknown. County and local government savings are indeterminable.
  • The bill text sets the general Class I payment at $42, but the fiscal note estimates using a $40 rate. The materials do not explain this difference.

What is unclear#

  • The current RSA 362-F text was not supplied, so the full change from current law cannot be independently checked. The fiscal note says the thermal requirement falls from 2.2% to 1.7%.
  • The bill’s payment rates are said to be fixed beginning June 30, 2025, although the bill’s general effective date is July 1, 2027. The materials do not explain how these dates work together.
  • The bill does not explain how removing Class II affects existing certificates, projects, or other renewable-energy programs.
  • The bill does not set new application, review, appeal, or reporting rules for the fund initiatives.
  • The fiscal note’s $40 Class I payment assumption conflicts with the bill’s $42 rate.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it simplifies the standards by removing a separate Class II requirement and placing solar electricity in Class I.
  • Allowing providers to meet requirements with certificates or payments gives them two compliance options.
  • The bill directs remaining fund money to renewable-energy and offshore-wind initiatives, while requiring the Department to seek approval to avoid interruptions to rebate and grant programs during a period without an adopted state budget.

Case against#

  • Removing Class II and lowering the thermal-energy share could reduce demand for some renewable-energy certificates; the bill materials do not estimate the resulting energy or emissions effects.
  • The estimated $1.2 million annual drop in fund revenue could mean less money available for supported initiatives, though the bill does not specify which programs would receive less.
  • The bill leaves project treatment and several implementation details unclear, making it difficult to assess who would gain or lose from the changes.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1612679

    Passed327 members voted

    OTPA

    FOR · 175AGAINST · 152

    175For

    • Republican175

    152Against

    • Democratic151
    • Republican1

    68 members were paired and sat out the vote.