Prohibiting the sale of certain gift cards that lack chip-and-PIN technology

Summary#

Introduction 615, sponsored by Council Member Linda Lee, would amend the New York City Administrative Code to prohibit sales of certain physical gift cards unless they use chip-and-PIN technology. The title describes the aim as prohibiting those sales; the bill is not yet law and is waiting in committee.

  • The ban would apply to cards marketed or labeled as gifts, bought in advance for a specified amount, and usable at multiple affiliated merchants or service providers, multiple unaffiliated ones, or ATMs.
  • Any person would be barred from selling or offering those cards for sale without the required technology.
  • A violation would carry a civil penalty of $500 to $1,000. Each failure involving a separate stock-keeping unit (a group of items with the same brand, quantity, price and variety) would count as a separate violation.
  • The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection commissioner must take steps to implement the law, including making rules, before it takes effect 120 days after becoming law.

What it means for you#

  • Gift-card sellers: If the bill becomes law, you could not sell or offer a covered card unless it has an embedded chip and requires a PIN to complete a purchase. In practice, sellers may need to stop selling non-compliant cards or obtain compliant ones; the bill does not set out how to do that.
  • Gift-card buyers: The bill would not cover every card called a gift card. Its definition requires a physical prepaid card marketed or labeled for gifting, with the listed uses and features. Digital cards are not included in that definition.
  • Shoppers and businesses generally: The bill does not create a new application or review process. It does not say who would investigate violations or bring penalty cases; it says penalties would be handled in a proceeding before the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets a penalty of $500 to $1,000 for each violation; separate stock-keeping units can count as separate violations.
  • No publicly available information gives the cost of compliance, rulemaking, or enforcement, or expected penalty revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not identify who would investigate violations or start cases before the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings.
  • It does not describe how the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection would implement or enforce the prohibition beyond requiring the commissioner to take necessary steps, including making rules.
  • The bill does not explain how sellers should handle existing inventory or what proof would show that a card meets the chip-and-PIN requirement.
  • The bill does not estimate how many cards or sellers would be affected, or the cost of switching to compliant cards.

Case for#

  • A possible case for the bill is that requiring a PIN for purchases would add a security step to the covered gift cards. The bill requires that step but does not establish how much it would reduce fraud or other losses.
  • The bill sets one rule for anyone selling the covered cards, rather than leaving the technology choice to each seller.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the ban applies to any person selling a covered card, including cards usable at ATMs, without exceptions or a transition period for existing stock.
  • Sellers may face costs to replace or stop selling non-compliant cards, but the bill gives no cost estimate or details on how sellers would verify compliance.
  • The bill sets penalties by violation and stock-keeping unit, but does not explain how cases would be investigated or how separate violations would be counted in practice.