Price disclosures by veterinary care facilities and publication of veterinary care facility price information

Summary#

Int. 1098-2026, introduced by Council Member Carl Wilson, would amend the New York City Administrative Code by adding rules for veterinary care facilities. Its goal is to make veterinary prices easier to see and compare. It has been referred to committee and is not law; it remains in committee.

  • Veterinary care facilities would have to display or otherwise provide standard prices or price ranges, routine fees, and circumstances that could change the price.
  • For a purchase that may cost more than $500, a facility would have to provide a written or electronic estimate before the consumer authorizes it, if the consumer asks and providing it is reasonably practicable.
  • Facilities would have to provide an itemized receipt upon request and disclose material conditions for an advertised price.
  • The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) commissioner would have to maintain a public website with quarterly updates of average prices for common procedures when enough data exists to calculate a statistically significant average. Facility names could not appear.
  • Violations could bring civil penalties: up to $500 for a first violation and additional violations that same day; $500 to $1,500 for each later violation.

What it means for you#

  • Pet owners: You could see standard charges or price ranges at the point of purchase, or receive them another way set by the commissioner. If a foreseeable factor changes a service’s price, the facility would have to disclose the factor and applicable charge or range. You could request an estimate for a purchase that may exceed $500, subject to the bill’s “reasonably practicable” limit.
  • Pet owners: You could request an itemized receipt. An estimate may differ from the final bill if you later purchase additional services, supplies, medications, testing, or other items.
  • Veterinary care facilities: You would have to make the disclosures and provide estimates and receipts as described above. The bill does not require a facility to recommend, provide, withhold, change, or stop treatment.
  • DCWP: The commissioner would have to create and maintain the price-information website and update it at least quarterly.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires DCWP to maintain and update a public website, but gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • Veterinary facilities may face costs to prepare and provide price information, estimates, and receipts; the bill provides no estimate of those costs.
  • The bill sets civil penalties but does not say how many violations might occur or how much revenue penalties might raise.

What is unclear#

  • The current Administrative Code was not supplied, so what price-disclosure rules already apply and how much this bill would change current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not say how DCWP would obtain price data for the website. It does not require facilities to submit data.
  • The commissioner would set how a facility may provide its price list instead of displaying it at the point of purchase. The bill does not give a deadline or process for setting that method.
  • “Common veterinary procedures” and “reasonably practicable” are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set out an enforcement process, such as how violations would be investigated or penalties imposed.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to help pet owners understand routine charges and possible price changes before buying services.
  • A possible argument for requiring estimates upon request is that a consumer facing a purchase that may exceed $500 could get written price information before authorizing it.
  • A public site with anonymous average prices could help consumers compare common procedures without naming individual facilities.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the price website may have gaps: DCWP would publish an average only when it has enough data for a statistically significant estimate, and the bill does not require facilities to provide data.
  • Facilities would have to maintain and share price information, but the bill does not estimate their costs or explain how to handle disputes over whether a price or estimate meets the rules.
  • Estimates are required only upon request and when reasonably practicable, and may not include later purchases. A consumer therefore may not receive a complete estimate of the final bill.